I moved to Florida from Jersey about a year ago. I've gone to so many pizza places here in FL and none of them know how to make pizza. This is the only place that knows how to make it taste similar to Jersey and NY. The pizza was amazing! I highly recommend☺️
The pizza was pretty good. I will definitely try again and not to mention, the staff was warm and welcoming. I'm from New York and though I visit, they have lots of great pizzerias around New York City and there are quite a bit similar to I Love NY Pizza and I really enjoy both theirs and the one here.
I ordered online, which was user friendly, and my to go order was ready sooner than promised. The Meat Lasagna and Chicken Picatta dinners were excellent and easily made two meals each. The staff was friendly and helpful, and my experience was excellent.
Absolutely fantastic pizza! The staff is friendly and upbeat :) I have ordered pizza twice this week! This is definitely my new favorite pizza place!
Fantastic pizza! Their margherita and Roma pizzas especially are superb. Also have great customer service, always polite and efficient on the phone, and courteous delivery drivers too. Best pizza in town, and worth every penny!
I love I love NY Pizza! I’m actually very partial to the pasta dishes they have. If you haven’t tried them you should try their chicken Francesca! So good!
Not sure if you guys know but a margherita pizza does not have the regular cheese on the pie. It should ONLY have fresh mozz as well as the tomatoes, basil, etc. This is the second spot I've been to in Florida that adds these things as a topping to regular pie instead of making a true margherita slice. You can literally Google it and see photos. I order margherita so I get less cheese and end up with double cheese. Pizza and crust are good enough. One of the few places you can get by the slice. Ordering over the phone during dinner time was hell and waited an hour to get the wrong pie.
they have the best pizza in the area. I work in the same plaza so its very convenient for lunch or dinner to go.
Pizza was ready as promised. Really tasty and great thin crust. Pretty close to what you can get in NY.
I used to live in New York and the pizza there definitely has a distinct taste and texture. I ❤️ NY pizza and Italian gator are the two places in town that come the closest to that classic New York taste. The reason why I prefer I ❤️ NY pizza is because you can actually go inside to order, eat in the patio, and there's parking. Not to bad mouth Italian gator I think they're great too but my bar going days are over I don't feel like competing with drunk college kids for a NY slice. So if I had to point you to a place for great NY style pizza, I'd send you to I ❤️ NY pizza