Ordered 2 steak and cheese gourmet rolls this afternoon! Absolutely delicious.. Usually my husband and I can only eat 1/2 but it was so fresh and delicious…we ate the whole thing! Definitely recommend!
I just ordered a large pepperoni pizzaand it was so delicious ?The crust was so fresh!The flavor was awesome!I would definitely recommend Goodfella’s
Placed an order for delivery at 2:30PM. Didn’t receive my order until almost 4:30PM. No communication from the restaurant until I called them. Turns out their driver was knocking on the neighbor’s door “for like 5 minutes”, when my address is clearly marked on the mailbox, because he “saw that they have 2 doors so”. What?! Of course the food was soggy and barely warm, plus I was missing an item on top of it. I opted not to even bother calling to report the issues because I refuse to deal with attitudes and wait 2 hours for a missing $3.25 single slice of pizza. I thought that they would be better now that they are in the new location but clearly I was wrong. Last time I ordered from them was unsatisfactory too but I figured I’d try again. Big mistake! Like many others in these reviews, this will be my last time frequenting this Goodfellas location. The staff at the 25th & Edwards are far more attentive, communicative and have great customer service.
Absolutely horrible. All I wanted was a slice of pizza with my daughter. Now first of all it took at least 10 mins of waiting in line just to place my order. The girl at the counter was too occupied with the phone and didn't pay any attention to the customers waiting in line to pace an order. When I did place my order (2 slices and 2 cans of soda) I sat down with my daughter and was waiting for them to heat my slices.. well about 15 mins later I approached the counter to ask how much longer for my order and the girl I placed order with had no clue what I ordered or why it wasn't ready. I had to tell her my order and again I had to wait. About 5mins later she attempted to hand me the wrong slices. At that point I asked to cancel my order and to be refunded. She gave me the $11 back and I left without having a slice of pizza with my daughter. That was my first time at this particular store and will definitely me my last.. ??
great pizza!!...and a thankyou to audra at the front counter...very friendly and helpful with our order. Greatly appreciated!!..LOVE the new store ...very clean, well maintained n convenient!!...will definitely order again.
I was a regular for two years and I’ve never had a burnt pizza before in my life! What happened to great cook that was there that used to make the best delicious pizza on the Island? I’m dumbfounded. This is not okay. This was after delivery too. It was already 8:30pm, I waited over an hour. They told me they could make me a new one but they would have to take the old one back. I can’t wait that long when I already waited and I work 7 days a week. My treat to myself was ruined this week.
Used to be so good! Now its 2 hour late cold tasteless food. Delivers are nice but staff working the phones are rude. Place has gone way downhill. No competition on the island yet but once there is I'm pretty sure they wont make it. Save your money and your time because its not worth it. Dont really bother trying to post a review to get a change because it seems no one gives a care. Will order anywhere else from now on. Pizza hut is a step up or maybe I'm going to try Angelinas Pizza , on the island
Strictly from a plain slice perspective, it's "very good". Enormous slices! Also had a motz & pepperoni roll which daughter loved.Special: 2 slices and drink for $6 was a deal.
Received regular wings instead of boneless. No dipping sauce. No silverware provided to eat our order of $70 plus. Then when I called you blamed door dash and us for not asking for silverware. What a joke. Horrible customer service. Save your money.
I went to goodfellas new ft pierce location and was disappointed, even appalled. The restaurant was cold and sterile. The chairs and stools were like torture racks...narrow and uncomfortable. Even the pizza didn't taste the same. Forget about a cold glass or mug for your beer, paper cups instead!I won't be back!!!