Vincenzo's Pastaria

16520 S Tamiami Trail #148, Fort Myers - 33908
162 reviews
Pizza Italian
(239) 489-1115

Finally great pizza!!! This is now our go to place!!!! We have been here for 3 years and have yet to find a decent pizza! We’re from Chicago and know good pizza, and even though this is NY style, it’s really, really good! Quality and plentiful toppings, sauce has great flavor and the crust was excellent. Happy to have discovered Vincenzo’s ?

We ordered our dinner on Grubhub. If our food tasted this good after delivery, I can only imagine how good it is at the restaurant! We will have to visit someday, but will continue delivery often.

The best pizza in Southwest Florida. Nice pleasant waitress and atmosphere!!

Today was the first time I've been in since Covid. The 2 slice plus drink lunch special is great. Huge slices of NY style pizza. When I'm working in the Forest, it's so convenient.

Our first time eating here is when we ordered takeout on NYE. They were quite busy and I took that as a sign that the food must be good. I was correct! Even though they were extremely busy, the staff was very friendly. And of course we were very pleased with the quality of the food. We will definitely be back.

If you are looking for authentic NY style pizza ? look no further then Vincenzo's. My favorite is there Quatto Formaggio, but any pie will do. They also have a great lunch special... 2 large slices (and I do mean large!) & a drink for $5.99 (give or take)... awesome deal for sure! If your new to the area, please check them out, you won't be sorry.... #1SatisfiedBrooklynGirl

Delicious pizza! We were in town and came across other Google reviews for Vincenzo's. We had an 18inch pizza and salads delivered. The pizza was some of the best I've ever had. It was hot, flavorful, perfectly cheesy but not greasy, and the dough reminded me of pizza from NYC. The salads were huge and the veggies were so fresh. Prices were great too. Next time we are in town we will definitely order again.

Everything tasted amazing and was so fresh! The portions were huge and lasted me many meals. Freshest ingredients that I've had at a restaurant in a long time.

I love this place!! They have an amazing lunch special for weekdays. Their food is always fresh. The pizza is amazing. The people are super nice. They never disappoint. I frequent this place often I think it’s the best pizza hands down.

Ordered a 18” white pizza for delivery & it was literally the WORST pizza I’ve ever eaten and my guests, agreed. It was dry, lacked any seasoning and tasted as if the cheese, especially the base, was artificial and rubbery. I was extremely disappointed and unfortunately, I forgot to notify the manager the next day to let him know. It was definitely not worth the $24 I spent on it!!!