Stevie Tomato's Sports Page

4420 Colonial Blvd, Fort Myers - 33966
260 reviews
Sports Bar American
(239) 939-7211

Seasoned wing fries are more like fries in hot sauce ?? it was good overall, but the fry concept is a little strange. The mozzarella sticks were great and so was the chicken. Spaghetti could’ve been better!

Went after noon. Ordered a $11 medium Pizza. We have ordered 5 or 6 other times and always get the same thing. 1/2 mushrooms and black olives, 1/2 onions and sausage. In the past this has counted as 2 toppings. Adds $4 to the pizza. $15 total. Check came and it was $19. We questioned the bartender, who has always been nice. She immediately caught an attitude. Just said she has to ring it in that way. I explained that 4 half toppings should equal 2 full toppings. She kept the same attitude. Just said she has to ring it in that way. We paid the bill but were not happy about it. She got a smaller tip than ever. We have always tipped high. In the past she had always joked around with us. Now, it seemed like she burned the bridge because we questioned the bill. We have not been back. This happened in October of last year. We go somewhere else every 2 weeks now. Always wanted to write this review hoping the management would change the policy. Finally doing it.

My Mahi Mahi sandwich was too salty and the smallest piece of Mahi I have ever seen on an over sized sub roll and it didn't even come with lettuce, tomato, or onion. My husband and friends had no complaints about their food, only the margaritas.Our margaritas were poorly made. Our friends margaritas looked far different than mine and my husband's. No consistency in the way drinks are made.Prices weren't bad and the service was very good. We had to wait longer than usual for the check, my husband had to go find the waiter to get our check. I think they were shorthanded.The atmosphere was nice and friendly also the waiter and entertainment was good. I would go back but I will not order the salty and very tiny Mahi Mahi sandwich or margaritas again.

My co-worker and I were feeling for wings all day at work. We're both from out of state and are still trying to find good restaurants. I decided to do a quick Google search and this place came up and it did not disappoint. She got the dry rub and I got the sweet and spicy. Believe me when I tell you everything was good. If you like your wings crispy but not dry and SUPER delicious. Next time I am going to try the Jerk because I am curious as to what it taste like. We washed it down with some Margaritas and closed out with THE Biggest slice of Carrot Cake I've ever seen. We shared a few bites and left the rest. The waiter was excellent and brought our food out so fast we didn't even need appetizers. There was also a band playing live music. The singer was really nice and was talking to us while setting up (this particular guy only plays on Thursdays there). I love the atmosphere and will definitely be taking my family there again.

It boggles my mind when I go in here and it's not crazy busy! The food is absolutely outstanding! Idk why anyone would go to a chilli's or Applebee's that does NOT cook the food, ONLY heats it upon ordering ? instead of here!? Do yourself a favor and get the fajitas my absolute favorite! Then give yourself a pass and order the chocolate cake.... PS ONE piece is enough to feed FOUR people!

Whereas I was somewhat underwhelmed by the "Chicago Deep Dish Pizza," the thin crust is pretty good and is quite similar to the thin crust you'd get at Giordano's. I especially like the Portobello style, which includes sausage, mushrooms, Hrande Mozzarella, and plum tomato sauce. (I added grated parmesan.) It's distinctive and worth the trip.

There are 3 Sports bars on Colonial Blvd. 1st visit here for dinner. at 630 on Thursday, place was full bit there were high tops near the bar. Bar tender super busy but managed to get our drinks and order in. Was surprised we didn’t have to wait too long for our food, B/c the kitchen looked backed up with tickets. When the appetizer came, the server did t bring a place setting or plates. I went over to the drink station and grabbed plates. After I did that, a didn’t employee came by to see if we were ‘ok’. The weird thing is there was this waitress walking around checking on her tables and if you went to get her attention and it was not her table she kind of brushed you off. I think all the servers should help each other especially since the bar tender had a full bar and had to come from behind d the bar to wait on us. The food…. fried zucchini not bad. Burger looked good. didn’t get fries so they must have been good and my Greek salad was ok. a few brown pieces of lettuce. Dressing was good. Garlic bread yummy. Nice family place. Music outside on Patio way too loud and not so good. Overall causal and fun place to grab a drink and food.

Great pizza and awesome service. Love their new location on Colonial Blvd.

We were surprised to get a table for 7 right away on a Friday evening. Our server was excellent .. she was hustling. We ordered a variety of food items . . no one complained . . .the mahi salad looked amazing and I wish I had ordered that . . . .3 of us split a pizza . .it was just ok . . it was also surprisingly not overly loud . .we could easily talk with a our dinner companions without having to yell. The had a nice patio area but it was hot and some of the group wanted AC as well as avoid those out there smoking . . .

First and foremost, REMOVE the word "SPORTS" from the name! The greatest comeback in NCCA Basketball Championship history and Stevie's has last call 10 minutes after tip off and closed 30 minutes later. MIND BLOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Time for NEW management folks.