We were told 60-75 min delivery and it ended up being 2 hours. Pizza is always cold. We’re done.
Pizza was decent. Probably the closest to New York style I’m gonna get around here.The garlic knots were very airy and fluffy. But- they were SOAKED in grease! If it wasn’t for all the grease they would probably be pretty good. Literally in a puddle of grease. I wish I took a photo.That’s all I tasted was grease.Good news, the grease was clean ? so they clean their fryers - that’s a plus :)
First time here, ordered pizza to go last night after work, a large pizza with sausage & cheese... delicious pizza!! Would've been 5-stars but too many black, burnt spots on the bottom of the pizza and no Army Veteran discount.It cost $29 for the one pizza, a 2-Liter soda, & a small can of soda. It's located right by the Hospital where I work, so, I'll go back... maybe it'll have less burnt places on the bottom of the pizza next time. :)
Based on ratings, I expected a much better pizza. We ordered take out (as they do not have dine in service due to staffing issues) a large pepperoni pizza. I lived and worked in NYC and my wife is from the Northeast so we hoped for a great pizza. True, you could fold the slices, but that is where the similarities ended. The sauce was not flavorful, the cheese was minimal, and the pepperoni was small rectangular pieces. Certainly not a good pizza. Not as bad as as several cheap chain pizzas, but anything special.
My go to! Moved down from up north, exactly like back home. By far the best pizza in SW Florida I’ve had!! Also their brownies are sooo good you can tell they’re homemade
Legit NY style pizza in Florida! The closest to NY I've had south of the Mason Dixon! Friendly service, great pie, cookies, and salads. You can order by the slice, but you'll end up ordering another and another, so get a whole pie.
Try one of the peanut butter cookies before you leave! Oh its heaven! Pizza was great too but next time i have got to try the cheese pizza! Love this place! Girl even helped me to my car with my order! Totally love this place!!
Great pizza ! Definitely cheesey !!! If in the area worth the stop !
I am a NY native, I have been in swfl for over 15 years. Good pizza is hard to find, this slice was better than good! A slice of heaven. My daughter and I had a slice each while we waited for a Sicilian pie to take home. I will definitely be back for the round pie,(I am already trying to plan my trip there) and probably try the Sicilian again and eat it there.
We devoured this pizza. This is really good NY style pizza. We will definitely be coming back.