We stopped here by happenstance. There was a terrible storm so this was our safe landing until things cleared.I personally thought the pizza was delicious. The best I've had in FL so far. Good chold drinks.Pretty basic otherwise but I liked it
It's very obvious this is an established and well run family business. The place was clean, the servers are smiling and the portions are bigger than average. The baclava and spinach pie were excellent?
I been to Nick & Stella's twice in a week, I met Stella she is very nice, the three friends I was visiting with, Leo, Vernon, and Bob. Have been taking me to all good places to eat. JOANNA THE BAR TENDER WAS VERY GOOD ALSO she remember what I drank from before. That is a very good bartender. I am sure we will be going there one more time, before I have to go back home.
3/2/2022 - I ordered boneless wings and got white meat tenders. When I questioned server she told me that's the way they make them. Tenders was not what I wanted. Menu should state boneless wings are just tenders and not actually a wing. Very disappointed.I need to apologize - I was expecting deboned chicken wings, not the chicken breast tenders I received. I did not realize that boneless wings are made from chicken breast meat. I did learn that they are supposed to be cut into wing size not flat like tenders. They did taste very good and I will definitely continue to eat at Nick & Stella's.
Went to Nick and Stella's with the family 2 days ago and it was 1 of the 3 worst pizzas I had ever eaten. At first it smelled odd when it arrived at the table. I put that aside and tried to put a piece on my plate. I was pretty amused by the lack of ability to break the 10 long strands of cheese coming from it. I love cheese like every pizza lover should but that changed after the very first bite. It tasted like straight up hamburger grease and dough. Now I know that ordering sausage and pepperoni on a pizza will make it greasy but that grease should taste like either sausage or pepperoni not hamburger! My sisters said theirs tasted bad too but they were hungry and ate a piece anyway. I didn't want to make my stepmother feel bad because she has been talking up the place up for a few months about how much better it was than another place further down the road, which had great pizza. I sent it back anyway. The waitress was understanding but kinda made it seem like it was my fault for ordering sausage. They did rush out a meatball sub that was adequate.I wasn't going to write a review because it may have just been that day and been a fluke. But a larger blonde woman came out of the kitchen and stared at me while chatting to the cashier and judging by her then looking my way, talking garbage.Obviously won't be back.
I rarely leave reviews, but the food was too awful not to warn people about. This was hands down the worst pizza I have ever eaten and I'm including cheap frozen pizza. It tasted like charcoal and grease. We ordered 3 different pizzas and they were all awful. We called the waitress over to complain and did exchange one for a meatball sub. At no time did the owner come over to find out what the problem was and talk to us. Save yourself and eat elsewhere.
Ordered online and was given a time to pick up my food. Drove to the restaurant to pick up dinner and when I walked in there was total confusion with several customers complaining about their food not being ready. The young lady explained to me that there was a problem and the my food would be 30 more minutes. I told her never mind. She took my contact information and told me that the Manager would call me the next day. That was 3 days ago and still have not heard from the restaurant and also my charge has not been refunded. Please stay away from this place unless you want to pay for food you don’t get.
So sad to see how downhill the service here has gone in the past year and a half. Long time customer, sports and beer enthusiast & off-season supporting local. Such rude service. Lisa, you should find a new outlet for your bad attitude.Empty drinks and condescending comments upon bringing our food, then being yelled at for resourcing to the bartender for another round, although we cashed out with him separately..because you claimed ‘you’d get in trouble’ . Then come to find out you added gratuity to part of our group and not the other half of us. Plain disgusting & rude behavior.Definitely not the same fun spot it used to be.Back to busters or mcgregor grill where our business is appreciated & the service is welcoming.
First pizza was cooked on top and mushy crust. I asked for well done when they remade my pizza and it came out the same. The oven is not working properly and needs to be looked at. Not heating evenly. Service was great. Not returning.
Every January, we visit our friends in Fort Myers. We love ❤️ KU Basketball, Nick & Stella's is KU's watch bar, and it never disappoints. The beer is always cold, the wings are awesome, and the pizza is my favorite. I Love This Place