DeNucci's

2210 Sadler Rd, Fernandina Beach - 32034
343 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Hot Dogs Burgers
(904) 310-6837

First time here. I wasn't sure what to get, but the friendly staff was helpful! There are a lot of options. I was torn between dole whip or frozen custard. I decided to get the frozen custard in a twist. It is SO creamy, filling, and good. Definitely want to go back. I would try this over other ice cream chains in the area. ??

Great little place! The portions are huge! I’d recommend sharing! Cute little place off Sadler and well shaded. Minus a star for service but even that was forgotten after getting our ice creams! I’d recommend this place!

I don't believe I've ever given a one star review of any establishment in my life as I would never seek to harm a local business's reputation but I think the one star is deserved. We are in town on vacation and realized the shop closes at 9 pm so we hustled to get there; we walked in the door at 8:40 pm amongst a line of about 10 people. The girl at the cash register greeted me and my two young daughters and toddler son with "hey the people who just came in the door-- sorry but we're not taking anymore orders tonight because the line is long." That was it. I looked at her for a moment to see if she was serious and she certainly was... Glanced at my watch and confirmed it was 8:40 pm. Another customer even loudly commented "wow what great service!" Obviously my young girls were distraught but we turned around and left and went to the Dairy Queen up the road. Very sad because I do try to support locally owned businesses everywhere we go but this was just unacceptable and terrible customer service. If an establishment closes at 9 pm, you should absolutely take customer orders until 9 pm. Period. I've never had another business turn us away because "the line is too long." Wonder if the owners/manager are aware of the early closings (have seen other reviews about the open sign being turned off at 8:15/8:30 despite operational hours till 9 pm). We probably won't be back.

Hands down the best , creamiest, thickest soft serve custard I’ve ever had. Almost a meal in itself!

Fresh ice cream. Nice to gave 2 non dairy choices. Employees try to move the orders fast Would return. Parking tight. Hope the Hilton next door doesn't mind.

Amazing little ice cream shop just off the road beside the Home2 Suites. They have the best service and the ice cream is fantastic. Portions are beyond generous, they're huge! They also serve actual Dole Whips, like at Disney! So good! Was a wonderful surprise. If you're in the area make a visit!

Been here a couple times, usually just ordering something simple like a vanilla cone. This last visit I decided on the Peanut Butter Lovers Twister and omg.... it was amazing! The cookie pieces in it weren't obliterated, they were big chunks and I think that was the best part. Crunchy and peanut buttery, what more could you want? Craving another one already.

The custard

I had a coffee ice cream drink and it was delicious! The portions are large and the prices fair. Found our new spot!?

We biked to this lovely spot and enjoyed every bit of it! The serving sizes are overly generous. The flavors were fantastic. One of our favorite things we did while on Amelia.