An award from CL Best of the Bay is what brought me here. I can see why they were awarded. While having a slightly different flavor portrait the results were very good. I had the New York Supreme, my go to when tasting, and there are some very nice flavor accents. The crust was crunchy and had that wonderful char I look for in a pie. The minced sausage is not a preference for me, but it sufficed. I noticed that they are expanding next door and will soon be twice the size. I do recommend Madison Avenue Pizza.
Taco pizza was not enjoyable. No flavors at all. Stick with their basics. They are good
Good food and friendly staff!!!
Excellent family owned pizzeria! Fantastic pizza, friendly staff and great atmosphere. Definitely go check them out!
Absolutely one of the best pizza places around. Fantastic staff and food. Will be going back again and again.
Ordered On-line. Picked it up at the exact time they told us to. Everything good like clockwork. We ordered a Bayshore. The peppadew peppers were great. Good pizza. We ordered a Caesar Salad and it was fresh and tasty. We’d do it again.
Madison Avenue is the BEST! If you’re looking for unique Pizza options with a phenomenal crust and friendly team members look no further! Treat yourself to some toasted ravioli while you wait and watch your pizza get made in-front of you! The Pickle pizza, Cuban pizza, Chick-fil-A pizza, Italian sub just to name a few are spectacular ! Just wow!!! Keep an open mind you will be pleasantly surprised about how well it works! Don’t even get me started on the Green bean casserole pizza that was beyond fantastic !!! The Stromboli is pretty on point too! My hubby and I love trying the pizza specials ! Never a dull moment!
Our absolute favorite pizza place in Dunedin. The weekly specials have quickly become our go to and I especially love their wings in the 5 boroughs sauce. Best wings in the area by far. Amazing customer service, quick delivery, and always a delicious meal. Highly recommend. Added my two personal favorite specials they have ran - crab Rangoon and the flaming hot chicken mac n cheese. Chefs kiss. Give them a try
We LOVE this place. Hands down our favorite pizza place! We drive 40 minutes one way just to get it. Perfectly cooked, crispy crust, fresh ingredients. They also have great chicken wings (we’re from Buffalo).
I was introduced to Madison Avenue pizza a few years back by some of my friends, and every single thing I’ve tried on their menu is absolutely delicious!!! My favorite thing ever is their speciality pickle pizza (sounds weird, I know, but it’s heavenly)! This past Friday I got their pickle pizza and also tried their toasted raviolis and they did not disappoint!! The five Borough wings are also incredible!! They are conveniently located right by the Dunedin causeway so it’s awesome for ordering to go pizza and heading to watch the sunset!! Fun fact, if you reheat your leftover pizza in a frying pan, it cooks evenly and tastes like it was just freshly made(heat in pan until it’s warm, then add a little bit of water next to the pizza and cover with a lid until the cheese melts!!)???