Amici's Pizzeria Cafe

4800 W Hillsboro Blvd A-17, Coconut Creek - 33073
199 reviews
Pizza Italian
(954) 428-4911

The truth of the matter is; the sense of Family dining has lost both its luster and glory over the years. I’m a millennial, I know what it’s like to read long posts and reviews, but for you that’s reading; Amici’s Coconut Creek; warrants a genuine paragraph or two. Service is not what it used to be! In my experience One can find a pizza joint within two mile of one another, though I highly doubt you will find one as heartwarmingly Nostalgic, such that is Amici’s. If I were to elaborate, we have lost a sense of the meaning of family friendly establishments. That’s what you will be reminded at Amici’s Coconut CreeK. Life is a family sport and the family at Amici’s; encompasses what dinning in a true family setting is to replicate. Though, of that tight nit family four individuals continue to raise the standard and rise to heights of great achievements. These four individuals stand out most to me. Their names are as followed: Craig- Owner, Jordyn- Hostess/Cashier, Guy- Executive Chef, and Nelson- Executive Chef. A disclaimer, very seldom; you will find individuals like the four wonderful names I mentioned above. Kindness has become a commodity in todays culture. Upon finding kind souls, like Craig, Jordyn, Guy, and Nelson; which is then centers around outstanding cuisine; what you then have is, Paramount! If you wish for one-of-a-kind Service, memorable experiences, and an open plate at the table; pull up a seat. Allow Amici’s to find a place in your heart, like they have found a place in mine. Craig (Handsome), Jordyn, Guy, and Nelson, thank you for your friendly smiles, thank you for your service, more importantly thank you for the meal; I will be back…5/29/2022Boca Raton, FL 33432Jéan Teneus

Love it!! First time and surely wasn’t disappointed on our first orders. The dough had a nice taste and texture; just the right balance. The calzone topping was overloaded.Ambience was very homey and with a friendly crew giving good service.Surely will drop by again to taste the pizza and other dishes on the menu.

Horrible experience. Ordered hot sub sausage sandwich... the bread was burned I told waitress please redo this time don't burn the bread.. brought another sandwich which didn't look any better.. kept this order and was disappointed..Then ordered same order to go with garlic chicken wings and the same waitress messed that order up tooooooo...They must have changed Cooks from the last time i visited this place

Had to try it out after tons of recommendations. Great people all around combined with a great atmosphere. Pizza was fantastic, can’t wait to try everything else soon.

Stopped in while waiting for a friend to grab a few slices and everything was delicious. The bbq chicken slice was scrumptious as hell, so freaking tasty. And the plain cheese was perfectly thin and crispy. Thank you!

We have been coming to this gem for the last 3 years. All I can say, take all of the 5-star reviews, combine them together and you will know what to expect. Not to mention AMAZING(!!!) pizza crust.

A Christian-owned Pizzeria with the highest quality food and nicest people out of any restaurant in the area! If you haven't gone yet, I urge you to. And if you have already... Do it again! È molto bene!

We used to love this place, but things went downhill. There were a few mishaps recently, like the 10 lbs of ricotta cheese in a calzone that ran like milk. That was gross. I let that slide.The kicker was the upside down pizza we ordered with black olives that contained at least 5 olive pits. Yes, olive pits. Luckily, it didn't cause any dental accidents and our 3 children that were eating it didn't choke.When we called to notify the staff, so that it didn't reoccur to someone else, the girl that answered the phone, claiming to be the manager, acted like she could careless with childish teenager attitude. It is EXTREMELY dangerous that you allowed olive pits to make it into the food. I know mistakes happen, but the complete lack of empathy afterwords was the icing on the cake.So, we're done. A loyal customer, gone. I actually had to edit this review -- it was a 5 star with good feedback. Sad. We were good for at least 1 order a week.Dominic's is better anyways.

Arriving at this little Italian restaurant was a total alternative stop....I started heading out for a steak restaurant, but the place i chose was so over crowded I ended up here on a fluke!But, to my surprise I found this friendly quality Italian joint...and I say joint because its small inside with limited seating, with a few tables outside...so if your eating in you might have to wait for a table if they are super busy....I sat down right away, no problem.I ordered veal parm meal, and the portions were just right from the salad to the bread sticks...and then the entrée and side of meatballs were perfect. My eyes were bigger than my stomach, but I finished as much as I could....enjoyed it all, I think the meatballs were a combo of meat and pork....I favor all meat WASP still like my mom used to make, but these were really good too, and the sauce everything was in tasted homemade!I'll be back soon.Thanks all, be safe.Charles

Fantastic food!!! My favorite for pizza and sandwiches!Adding an update because I'm so happy I just tried dinner platters which were delicious with very large portions. Also great brownies ?