Original Anthony's NY pizza

1455 FL-436, Casselberry - 32707
163 reviews
Pizza Italian
(407) 657-5384

You MUST fix the sticky tables. They have been like this for months. They aren't, dirty. They're ruined from disinfectant. Just re-finish them already. Otherwise, amazing food, large portions, great price and wonderful staff.

I ordered from Anthony's yesterday for the first time.I was trying to order fettuccine alfredo but their menu is so confusing. I was trying to get fettuccine affront with mushrooms. I ended up with fettuccine with red sauce, which was delicious but I'm allergic. Then I got a side order of Alfredo sauce. Garlic knots were great. Just needs to clarify menu.

Honestly the best pizza ever I love going there me and my family have been getting pizza from them for 12 years now and their pizza always tastes amazing. The staff is super friendly and provide great service. The restaurant is also very friendly

I love going to this restaurant the cooks are very friendly, and the waitresses are nice but my favorite one is Shirley she’s so friendly and sweet. Always with a smile she makes you feel like you are at home.Thank you for your services.

The best pizza spot in central Florida. I wish their name was different, so no one would get them confused with the other Anthony’s pizza places with similar names. This place is a hidden gem and I will forever be a loyal customer. So yummy!!

Look I love this place an it hurts for me to write this review about 50 minutes ago my wife ordered a xtra-large calzone with unions, peppers, pepperoni, bacon and ham and a xtra-large pepperoni pizza. First off I know this part is not Anthony's fault, but I did my due diligence to let Uber know the driver does not follow instructions. My food was supposed to be handed to me instead she left it on the floor outside and I had selected meet in person. I did grab the order immediately it was left outside to my surprise the pizza was barely warm. (keep in mind I live across the street) so food always arrives very hot. The calzone was a disaster no flavor and the veggies where not even fully cooked I felt I was eating a cold sub. The dough was not fully cooked. The experience was terrible and the food was disgusting. Sorry Anthony's, but you dropped the ball =(

I like this place. The people who work there are really nice, The ranch is really good and the portion size is really good. The pizza is good, fresh ingredients and tasty.

Great pizza salad really fresh . Wish it was closer to my location

One of the best pies around! Their sauce is delicious and their dough is crunchy and bubbly. They are generous with their cheese and you get that pull apart cheesy goodness while the dough is still crispy and hot. The staff is very friendly and willing to go out their way to make their customers feel both welcome and satisfied. We had a special request and they were game for it!!! Super cool and family oriented so bring your folks down and have a great experience!

Amazing pizza, awesome service, great place to get pizza. Personal rating 9.1 must try