Best lobster roll I have had in Florida since moving from Boston! Definitely going back for more!
It was my 1st time in this little pie shop. I went hoping to find a fresh made Boston Creme Pie for my husband's bday. They didn't have one, but they made one special and ready next day. It was all made from scratch and so delicious!! (I wish I would have taken a picture). I also ordered a lobster roll while there and it was amazing!! I can not recommend this place enough. Please support these smaller businesses. ✌?
The best Key Lime pie hands down !! Friendly staff, awesome sandwiches too.
This is an unbelievable place with fresh everything!! We pre-ordered 200 clams (middle necks)for a party. Going to do this more often. Under new management and still the best !! 10 stars!!
Best pies ever. We tried both the key lime and the chocolate cream. They were great. We also had both the cuban and the lobster roll. Terrific. Can'r wait to go back!
Having grown up in Key West, and having the privilege of eating Miss Ruby's Key Lime Pie, any place that tells me theirs really good or authentic makes me pause. This was my first visit to Mermaid Pies so, of course, in addition to the delicious Quiche Lorraine I bought (to pass off as my own...kidding) I had to buy their Key Lime Pie. It was fantastic, right up there with Miss Ruby's! Miss Ruby Bradley was my grandmother and a fifth generation Conch. Her pies were among the best made by old-time conchs. Except for the untraditional topping, which should be meringue (Miss Ruby's made hers with a little brown sugar), this pie made me homesick. YES I’ll be back.
We tried a couple different key lime pies during our visit to the area, but Mermaid Pies are the best!
THE BEST ROLLS EVER!!!! Thee end...
Another great piece of pie! Today was pecan. 15 seconds in the microwave brought all the yummy pecan goodness out like it just came out of my own oven. Thanks for a delicious treat!
Award-winning Pies and more - Cuban sandwiches and lobster rolls!! This is a little hole in the wall - locals know about. They only make the best!!