When we lived up the road from here, we ordered all of the time. The salads are plentiful, the pizza is true New York style and the bread is good as well. Good for a family night or a get together! Or just a couples night. I recommend!
We really like the food and we like the service. The lunchtime specials bring us back often. I like the variety of salads.
I have been there many times for pick-up and have always enjoyed the food. I tried many of there dishes and haven't had anything we didn't like. Try the meatball roll.
I have been there many times for pick-up and have always enjoyed the food. I tried many of there dishes and haven't had anything we didn't like. Try the meatball roll.
The crust was very thin and soggy. The sauce was tasteless. Not an Italian flavor. Garlic and spices missing. Name definitely leads you to believe the pizza would be much better.
Got stuck eating Marcos crap a few times for convenience. This place blows it out of the water. Finally some good pie!
Although I have eaten in this particular NYPD Pizza (I believe there are 2 others reasonably close by) as is the case with all places these days everyone has been pickup. The Pizza tasted great and was a great value, the salad was fantastic and everything was ready in the time promised. Although you can go in and pay if you prefer the Pizza, or whatever Italian Dish you order, can be brought to the car. Pizza has always been one of the best take out dishes, especially for those who don't mind if your Pizza gets a little cold or if you have to reheat it (I prefer mine hot out of the oven). Sponsor your local pizza place.
We love their pasta but, when I ordered two pasta dishes to go and I asked for extra sauce, they gave me a tiny cup and charged $3. The sauce on pasta evaporates when it is reheated. I was very disappointed. If we were sitting in the restaurant, we would have been given a bowl of sauce. Also the garlic rolls were hard. They must have been nuked too long.
I’m not even rating off food quality. More of a service rating. I understand the pandemic issue causing businesses for take out might be busier than usual.. but OH MY GOODNESS!! I placed an order through DoorDash I waited over 1.5hours when I finally called they said they were busier than usual, I was told another 20mins., okay, long story short I ordered at 7:23pm and my pizza didn’t arrive until 9:45pm! Enough said!!! And no this wasn’t a DoorDash issue, because the moment I called the restaurant the status on the app change. I think they forgot the order and neglected to send it out quickly.
Seriously the best pizza in Boynton and PBC. Worth the wait!!