Really really good….
First time here and I was very impressed. Growing up in New England I’ve always had fresh lobster and I’ve been to other places around here where I could tell it wasn’t. Mystic is different, in that it is fresh and they have a cool variety of lobster rolls I’ve never seen before! The pricing is very fair and the quality is great. The owner and his wife are wicked cool and their customer service was great. Would highly recommend for one of the best lobster rolls in the area!
A new acquaintence had a small gathering at her house and ordered pickup at Mystic Lobster Roll Co. I am not sure of the cost of this because I did not pay, but the Lobster sandwiches were delicious !!! The Lobster was fresh and tasty - what a heavenly spring treat !
The Closest And Best Lobster Roll by far!!! We have tried so many lol. The buttered and grilled roll is stuffed with lobster and made exactly as we are use to! From Boston! The Clam chowder was exceptional. What a Great find for us since we use to have a similar restaurant/take out.
VERY DISAPPOINTED with the TINY sized roll.When they first opened, I was in there all the time literally like every week because the sandwiches were twice the size. Since this summer I’ve been in there three times and the sandwiches are half the size now. It’s literally a kid size roll with less than a quarter of a pound of lobster on it. The lobster is very good but to pay $47 for two tiny kid size rolls with a little bit of lobster is a complete rip off. And there are many other places right on Palmetto to get lobster rolls. This is insulting to the customers. They are very nice so I hate to leave a bad review but honestly I will not be back I am way too disgusted.
Amazing, amazing, amazing. What more can I say..This place exceeded my expectations and what a great location, by the beach. It’s family owned, and from the first greeting to the end when we paid, 5 stars all the way. Food was fresh and delicious. If you are looking for an authentic Lobster Roll, I would highly recommend giving this one a try.
Lovely little shop, newly opened located not far from the beach in Boca Raton. We went to try their lobster rolls. I had the New England, which is lobster with mayo, mixed greens and lemon, while my wife had the Connecticut, which is served warm with melted both. Both were served with a side of delicious cole slaw. Excellent and worth a visit. BTW - the Mystic in the name has nothing to do with Connecticut, but rather New Jersey.
Super place for a bite before or after the beach. Friendly, family owned by a couple from Brooklyn. Had lobster bisque and it was full of chuncks of lobster. Also had the Conn. and Main lobster rolls. Full of 100% lobster. Roll was toasted just right. Coleslaw and pickles were delish too. We will be back.
I mean cmon- best lobster roll ever!
Honestly I spend most of my time in Maine and this was wayyyyy better than that. This place has huge portions and killer freshness. Don’t skip this place or you’re missing out!!