Pizza is way too salty!! It would be delicious if they would ease up on the salt. I couldn’t eat it all because of that
Great pizza! But if you are getting delivery not only do they charge a delivery fee but they charge for every little thing you might need such as a little bit of extra parmesan cheese or can I have a little bit more dressing with my salad?? We spend a good amount of money there so if we need parmesan cheese or if we need a little bit of extra salad dressing for a salad it should be given and not 50 cents for every little tiny container I think that's ridiculous. Also the woman who normally answers the phone can either be half nice or rude.
We ordered a large pepperoni pizza last night and it was under cooked absolutely no flavor at all. My husband ate a slice and I ate a slice and that was enough. We've been going to Anthony's for years but the quality has gone down, we've gotten calzones also and under cooked as well. If you call and complain they are rude and act like it's your fault, no customer service at all. There are too many other pizza places we can go to and I'm tired of Anthony's pizzas inconsistency. Save yourself time and money.
On March 29,2022 @ 8:50A cashier touched a pizza slice, right in front of my face. I gave her back the slice, and kept the rest of the pizza. Too dangerous to eat pizza touched by a person who handles money. Money that is touched by everyone else. I’m disgusted.
The customer service was great, and the meatlovers calzone was super good. Definitely coming back here again.
Anthony really outdone himself every time I place my order I'm good
Called and asked for two slices. Was told they only have 1 slice left. Huh???!!!!!This is a pizzeria. You make pizza. You don't run out of pizza. Well when youake all your pies at open and that's it's, you run out of pizza. No thank you. I don't want 5 hr left out pizza. SMH
Terrible customer service and after going I see why! Management was completely derogatory and openly rude to staff even with customers standing around. No wonder they're short. One extra star for food quality on the rare chance you can actually order some.
Been coming here for years, but never tried the pizza. WHAT WAS I THINKING!!!! We ordered 3 extra large pies for Christmas Eve and they were the hit of the family gathering. You can be sure we'll make this our new tradition... and throughout the year!
Sorry but I’m Italian born and raised in Jersey and this is far from New York anything. Got the Sicilian pizza and was nothing more than a thick crust with cheese and sauce on top. I mean it wasn’t baked right, flavor was ok and the cheese was just lying on top. The chicken parm sub was just about not eatable. It was so dry and the skin came right off the chicken. My first time and definitely my last!