Jerry's Pizza & Subs

924 W State Rd 436 #1300, Altamonte Springs - 32714
182 reviews
Pizza
(407) 682-4943

As a native New Yorker, Jerry’s delivers a true taste of home. Authentic and obviously made with love, their pizza is the best in the area. Run, don’t walk, to get their $5.99 two slices and a drink special! I promise you won’t be disappointed.

Have only tried the pizza and knots so far but have been happy every time. We love the standard cheese and get the white when we want variety. I would compare the crust to a Brooklyn style from Dominos, which is great since it's been impossible to find that from a local joint around here. We usually go around dinner time and have never had to wait forever after arriving at the estimated pick up window. Pic included is the 20 inch and it's just as good as the pic suggests!

Closest I've found to a true NYC pizza. Thin crust and the perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Most Florida pizza goes way too heavy on the cheese...Jerry's gets it perfect! Super nice owners as well. What are you waiting for? GO!

Pizza and subs are great! The customer service and employees are always very friendly and make the experience in the restaurant a lot more pleasing. I’ve never had a bad meal eating at Jerry’s.

Food is always amazing. The meatball calzone and meatball pizza is so good, highly recommend

Just moved from NYC to FL and am in love with their pizza! Have eaten there several times, after 7pm (they close at 8pm). Never had an issue getting their special. Except tonite. Arrived at 7:35pm and was denied the offer because they were "low on ingredients". Yet they offered a whole pie to go! Much as I love their pizza, I am a senior with a fixed budget and can't afford it. Wish they would advise customers AT WHAT TIME their special is unavailable before going into the store and being so thoroughly embarassed! Don't know if I'll be back . . .

While the pizza may look decent. I paid extra for extra cheese and there is no extra cheese. Pizza tastes ok.

Good quality for a fair price. Family owned and operated, a staple of the community I'll pay 6 bucks for their lunch special anyday before I stop at Mickey D's

We have definitely found our new pizza place!! Best, thin pizza we we have found. My husband got meatballs on one of his slices and they had so much flavor. Extremely friendly staff. Can't wait to try their other menu items.

Been coming here for years! Our favorite pizza place. Looking for authentic NY pizza then look no more. Family owned and operated too. They are all so nice there too!!