Horrible experience. We wanted to try something different and totally regret it. We ordered for pick up. A large pizza half cheese and half margarita with bacon. Sauce and cheese were missing on the cheese half so basically one slice of bread. The other half never saw the basil of the Margarita but the worst of all it was sooooo burned that ended doing a frozen pizza that we had. Never again!!!!!! When I called to complained the lady said to wait 5 mins are you serious ??? So far the worst pizza I ever had in 8 years I lived here. Waist of money and waist of time because we live 20 mins away from this place.
I mean … it’s a good idea ….. I’ve had this pizza four times now and the fourth time we decided to go take out ….. it’s way better fresh at the restaurant but still was missing something we were looking for in fire brick pizza …..We literally live 10 mins away and by the time we got home, the pizza quality changed.To be honest the best pie we’ve found in town is Tomasino‘s about 15 away … they just do it right when it comes to pizza.We think this place deserves a three star, but it lacks flavor and quality from the dough… and trust me … we are foodies!!!!!???
Enjoyed a really great earlier lunch here this week. Location has a nice, comfortable decor, the staff were very attentive and prompt in getting my order and then my food out to me.The garlic knots and the Carnivora pizza were very tasty, piping hot, and very fresh.This isn't one of the "fast casual" watch-the-pizza-being-made places, but you can place a to-go order if you like. They also have a full-service bar here that the locals seemed to like.Very worth stopping in for some great pizza and other great food!
Great job on the pizza, be it the sauce, quality ingredient or the coal fired oven it's cooked in. Plenty of other options on the menu, salads or sandwiches, all in large portions, served in a timely fashion, in a clean, modern environment. The wings are also cooked in the oven so they're not oily not greasy and taste great. Prices are on the high side, inflation appears to have caught up with Anthony's.
Ever since we moved to Altamonte, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza has been on our “Must Try” list. I’m happy to report we were not disappointed - friendly servers, a clean interior and delicious food!Even though pizza is their name, Anthony’s also offers appetizers, pasta, specialty sandwiches and dessert. We started with their garlic knots (DELISH!) not too oily which I appreciate as well as their Eggplant Marino. Oh so yummy! The sauce.. *chef’s kiss*We then shared a square, thin-crust Margherita pizza. Presentation was lovely! We ended up ordering more of their marinara sauce for dipping. It was THAT GOOD!Overall, delicious! Highly recommend! We WILL return!The only critique we had was our table was wobbly and made cutting slightly difficult - an easy fix.Thank you for the yummies!c & c
My new spot for pizza. Fresh ingredients, so no acid reflux or heart burn after wards. Great prices. Made fresh and served hot.
Been here a few times over the years but this is the first time that I’ve been since the beginning of COVID. There is definitely a downgraded feel about the place ( the restaurant & service). It was cozier & more upscale before, the kind of place where you’d be Ok with a $100 bill. Pizza, beer, & wings were delicious as always but a tad overpriced considering the current service and atmosphere but thats a lot of restaurants nowadays though.
Best pizza I’ve had in a long time, the food is amazing and super fresh. We ordered a traditional pie, wings and garlic knots and it didn’t disappoint at all. The staff was very attentive and arrival of the food was fast. Overall a great dining experience. Would def recommend
Excellent service and food is always amazing here!
Not bad, but not really NY style pizza I was looking for. Ordered a cheese pizza as it’s how I grade all pizza shops. Way too much tomato flavor for my taste. You taste the tomato more than the cheese. If you like tomato rich pizzas then it might be for you but I like to taste the cheese. Crust was good. A little burnt in spots but I kind of like it that way and crispy. They have good ingredients, but don’t like how it’s put together. Pizza didn’t have enough cheese on it, didn’t even have a cheese stretch when pulling slices apart. Not terrible pizza, but not the best in the area either.