I was sadly disappointed. I've been craving fries and a chicken Cheesesteak all-day. The fries were overcooked, and The chicken cheesesteak had a fish taste. This is the second time I'm ordering this, and both times, the fries have looked and tasted overcooked, and some of them were soaked with oil. Overall, I hope this won't happen again as I have enjoyed their other foods
My go to pizza joint. Best pizza around hands down. Fries can be soggy which is disappointing. The fry bags they use do not keep hot- just make them soggy. Pasta dishes are incredible, but way too expensive. Staff is nice. The wait is typical. They’ve messed up an order for me once, but easily fixed my problem. Interior of Cafe Sitaly feels so crammed & a bit unclean. No where to wait for an order. All in all, I am satisfied with the food. They could really benefit from expanding into a larger location!
Mrs. and I eat there weekly. Never had a bad meal. Their pizza is the best. Forget the national chains, get your pizza from Cafe Sitaly.The ambiance is a bit off-putting, buy the food and staff are great.
Here I am with all thoughts on ordering a meal for my family for delivery which I always get from here! To find out only pizza or strobili! Told them I would wait an hr or so! Said no! Well as much as I patronize this place and my family! Done!!! You can't run a biz like that! Very disappointed!! Never in my life have I ever heard this!! Va fun goul!!!
Just happened to find this place by accident On a Friday night, very Busy, Had to wait for a seat but the weight was worth it.. Absolutely delicious just can't wait to go back and have more.
What can I say the food is terrific and especially the fresh made bread is to die for.I highly recommend giving it a try.??
Had a really nice dinner here. The food is really good and our waitress was very nice.
Grandma pizza crisping is the best i’ve ever had. Eggplant parmigiana pasta dish is so good! ? ? ?
Balsamic slice was amazing, wonderful ambiance. Can't wait to try desserts next
Stopped in for the first time and I'm so glad I did. From the slices to the snickers cake everything exceeded my expectations.Cafe Sitaly is my new pizza place.