Love Nicola pizza! Great service as well!
Alway love the nicoboli’s and great place to take the family. Have been coming here for many years and looking forward to visiting their new location when it opens.
We've been going to Nicolas for over 25 years. Their signature dish is the Nic-o-boli, and I have never gotten anything else there. My kids love their pizza. They currently have two locations in Rehoboth Beach, but this is changing as they're moving north to Lewes Beach in the near future. I can't wait to see the new location! This is a family run business, and the staff are very friendly, but extremely busy. Your waiter/waitress is not dedicated to your table, so any staff walking by can assist you. That makes it hard to tip based on service of one person, but we have never had trouble with our orders. If you're in the Rehoboth Beach area, definitely make this one of the places you eat. You won't be disappointed!
We came to say good bye to their original location by having nicobolis and beach fries. They have a friendly atmosphere, great food and professional.
I’ve lived in California, Texas, North Carolina, Virginia; I’ve traveled coast to coast- and this is the WORST, food I’ve ever tasted. To call it pizza is an insult to pizza. Delaware is probably the worst food state I’ve ever visited. Their food is trash, their beach is trash and their pizza is trash. I don’t know why the locals like it. It makes me sad for them. Please eat real pizza and then come back here and you’ll get it. It’s pure trash, don’t eat it. It’s flavorless and just, mind boggling to me that it’s even a successful business.
We didn't have a chance to eat here, but stopped in for happy hour. Good, friendly service! The owner greeted us and found us a seat at the bar.
On Saturday April 23 as we strolled the boardwalk and shopped we took a lunch break for pizza. It was packed we got the last table. The pizza was delicious with an extremely tasty sauce which I really enjoyed. We commented to our waiter about the huge bucket of delicious looking French fries we saw being brought to various tables. He surprised us with a dish of fries for us to sample. It was one of our best lunches ever.
It will be a sad day for me when Nicola Pizza closes at 8 N 1st St. in Rehoboth! I've been eating there since 1975 - four years after they opened. To this day, it is the first place I go to eat when I come to Rehoboth, and the last place on the way out of town. The Nic-O-Boli is genius! Perfect dough, sauce, beef, and cheese! I sometimes get onions or pepperoni and it NEVER disappoints! Get their salad too! Romaine and iceberg with onions and shredded cheese. Always cold, fresh, and crunchy! The beach fries are amazing! Fresh spuds, fried golden brown and delicious! The baked ziti with sauce, beef, and cheese is delicious too! Let's not forget the pizza! They make the best pizza in Rehoboth! I've eaten all over the east coast, and they have the most wonderful food! Great staff, just amazing!
Always bump into friends or acquaintances here. The Nic-O-Boli is something I always look forward to when going there. BUT there is an intense rivalry with their pizza.
Wonderful staff and service. Great location! Conveniently located downtown. Always consistent with awesome food. Favorite is the white pizza with bacon and tomato