Nutter's Sandwich Shoppe

1219 Nottingham Rd, Newark - 19711
165 reviews
Sandwich Shop
(302) 731-4672

They do not skimp and make a nice fat sandwich for you. Try the chicken salad..it is delicious. Parking and leaving can be a challenge with traffic sometimes

I would give 5 stars but they toasted my bread and it was too hard to eat. Food is great otherwise and staff are really nice. Next time I'll ask them not to toast my bread. Make it an option please.

Very Friendly, Staff made recommendations and they bring your order out to your car when it’s ready :) The Crab Bisque & Cuban Sandwich are Delicious! Will be Back!!!

Today I went to try Nutter's for the first time. I ordered the cuban. 10 minutes later, when they brought it out to me, they had the wrong order and had to go back and remake it. Another 5ish minutes pass, apologize and hand me my order. I get home, open my order: italian sub and crab (?) fries. It s a good sandwhich, but this is not what I ordered. Also getting in and out of that parking lot is a nightmare

This was our first time ordering from there. One of the best things was, you were greeted with a friendly ? sincere "hello" as soon as you walked through the door, by the staff. That was really refreshing. We had the crab cake special. One crab cake sandwich and the crab cake platter. Both were very delicious. The Homemade Crab Bisque was DEE? LICOUS. Hot when served and the "soul slaw?" was great! It was a little hike for us, about 7 miles but, it was worth it and we can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Thank you "Nutter" for a delicious meal and a wonderful experience ?

I ordered a $28 lunch online @ 1p and arrived @ 1:30 to pick up and was told it wasn't ready, which was ok. i asked how much more time and was told 5 minutes and they offered to bring to my car, when ready. Thought that was nice but after seeing 3 other orders brought out to others and waiting another 16 minutes (making it 1:46), I called to see if they forgot about me. Finally as I was about to leave, she comes out but goes to another person to complain about the way they were parked. I asked through the window, while in reverse to leave if the order in her hand was for me and she eventually came over to rudely with attitude said, "your pick up time was 1:43p, its barely that" and basically threw the order in my car and then walked away even though I was trying to say something. If there is a specific pick up time , it should be displayed PRIOR to making the purchase online. Also, give a realistic timeframe if the customer arrives too early and certainly don't be rude. Unless that specific employee apologizes I won't go back again and will ensure everyone I know doesn't either. Her customer treatment was totally uncalled for and disappointing. To be clear, the other employees were fine...it was just the one who brought it out.

Great sandwiches and subs. The meatball sub is outstanding. The crab bisque was very well executed.

Best crab bisque, wonderful fudge, delightful service. Parking is a pain but with food this good who cares!

Great food. Always busy especially lunch. Might take some time to make.

Sad to say todays visit will be our LAST visit to Nutters. Ordered a PICK UP order of a few soups for our guys at work and a couple wanted chicken salad from the cooler. They refused to sell me two single serving containers of chicken salad because "their stock was LOW, only ONE per customer"... well technically we WERE 5 customers but now were ZERO customers. Your a CARRY-OUT sandwich shop! This should be against the law, you have something for sale, I have money to buy it yet you refuse to sell it! shame on you! Thanks to Wawa for providing our chicken salad today and in the future!