Argilla Brewing Co. @ Pietro's Pizza

2667 Kirkwood Hwy, Newark - 19711
139 reviews
Brewpubs Pizza
(302) 731-8200

I visited this place on June 12, 2022. I ordered shrimp tacos. I found 4 small pieces of rubber band mixed in the tacos. What it was most appalling and disappointing to me, it was how the manager responded. He said there was nothing like a rubber band in the whole restaurant so it couldn't be possible it came in the food. He added , if it was in the food it would melt. He clearly implied I put it in there. There was not one apology.I never asked for a discount or anything special.

I ordered shrimp tacos and to my surprise I found small pieces of rubber bands in my food. The manager said there was nothing similar to what I found in the entire restaurant so it was impossible it came mixed in my plate. He even added it would have melted if it was in my food. I was appalled and humiliated by his lack of costumer service skills.

Love Argillas! Another great Freddie pie last night along with some good beers and great service from Maddy outside with our pooch. Never disappoints.

Pizza is the best, A bit pricey. If you want a couple of slices, be prepared to pay a lot for very small slices. If any one knows about the old locations, that's when the Pizza was on point. What they really need to do is open just a Pizza joint,(keep the restaurant) but get back to the basics. Bigger isn't always better.

We absolutely love Pietros. The food is always absolutely amazing. The service is the best. Awesome inside setup. Beautiful outdoors arrangement. Pietro's is the top restaurant/bar/pizza shop together and separately in the entirety of kirkwood highway.

My wife and I went here to see a live show. We were seated completely out of view of the small stage. We saw friend's who were seated closer and asked the staff of we could sit at their table when they left. The hostess allowed us to move. Ten minutes later the owner demanded we move because he thought we had simply taken the table. After forcing us to move in a very aggressive manner, the owner then queried the staff and returned to our table away from the stage and grudgingly allowed us to return to our friends table. This owner literally expressed anger in this event and refused to listen to our explanation as to why we switched tables. My wife was shaken by the owners aggressive behavior and I was simply wondering how this man stays in business. We will never return. Food was average pizzeria fair. Sad the owner could not contain himself long enough to listen to a customer. He should have talked to the hostess first before aggressively approaching my wife and I. Avoid, there are much better brew pubs in the area.

Really want to love this place but it's just so inconsistent, from the decor to the food. The place looks really nice from the outside and they have a beautiful sign, but once you get inside it just looks dingy. The food and drink are similarly inconsistent. They had 2-3 beers on the menu that were amazing but the rest were just meh. The only good food I've had on the menu is the pizza; the fish tacos (WAY over-seasoned), tots (way over cooked), etc. just didn't taste good and were extremely greasy. The beer pretzels were too dense/over-cooked and greasy. I tried two different white pizzas with different toppings that were both excellent. However we also tried the pig & pineapple bbq pizza which was just not good at all. The pineapple was dry/rubbery and not sweet and the bbq sauce flavor was basically all you tasted. The only plus on this pizza was the house made sausage; you could tell it was house made when you tasted it by itself because it was excellent.Bottom line: a place like this needs to focus on what they are already doing well, improve upon that and get rid of or completely revamp what they aren't doing well in order to be great. The menu should be shorter to accentuate what they do well so people aren't disappointed and they should improve the interior decor. These would be vast improvements.

I’ve come to this great place for years. Their pizza, wings and food are fantastic. Tonight was no exception. It was St. Patrick’s day and the place was hopping. They had wonderful live music. Our server Ethan was the best: Pete takes care of the whole place. We will always celebrate here!

Best pizza and beer around. An amazing combo and a great neighbor bar. Once you enter the establishment you feel right at home. I come here often and they never disappoint. Tell a friend to tell a friend and let's all enjoy some Argilla.

Pizza and cheese steaks are both awesome! Not really a beer drinker but if I'm in the mood for a beer this place has some of the best around.