I usually don’t take time write reviews but I ordered 3 eggplant parm subs and a plain cheese pizza. The eggplant was raw on one of them, the bread was stale on all 3 and there was barely any cheese on any of them. I gave it one star because the pizza was ok. I know inflation is crazy but it doesn’t excuse making people pay for an inferior product by skimping on things and using old bread. If the inflation is hurting that bad perhaps only serve pizza or shut down until you can get it together to make edible food
Excellent abizza pie, our favorite since Dominic's. Grew up on another local favorite pizzeria, and this is our favorite since about the last two years. Great people and staff.
Delicious! The Baybrook white pizza is particularly good, the mashed potato too. They’re also cooked right with a great crust.
Love this place.... about to order a couple of grinders
Pepperoni and Cheese pizza here is one of the best in town period. Idc what anyone says
An absolute go to for Pizza in West Hay. It's by far the best pizza on the shore and always a pleasure seeing the staff and the vibes!
Darn good pie, always tasty. I always get a meatball sub too, so good!
I heard good things about The Salty Tomatoe, so I tried it today and I'm disappointed. The Ziti and Meatball dinner comes with 1 meatball that's been crushed or played with. The cheese pizza was under cooked but still good.
We have been getting pizza here from the start. Very good pizza and chicken parm grinder is outstanding.
Excellent steak and cheese subsPizza good. She definitely learned to make from her daddy., who helps out quite a lot. All the staff is nice