The Pickle Barrel

1889 Main St, Stratford - 06615
169 reviews
Sandwich Shop
(203) 380-0338

Pretty solid spot for lunches and breakfasts with a ton of variety in meals, drinks and sides.I like to call in ahead of time because sometimes there can be a wait, but with a place with good food, that only makes sense!

Pickels are the Bestoh sandwiches are too lol great place !!!

We ordered The Pickle's famous party sandwiches and they were as delicious as we remembered them to be. We are so glad we ordered them and Teresa was really helpful when taking my order.

Today was my first time there the sandwich was awesome will be going back

Ok let's do it. I was really hungry wanted something quick my friend says let's go to the Pickle Barrel there food is blazing. It was right across the street. I said I heard about the sandwiches but breakfast? He's like yeah it's good let's go. Sorry I think.he lost his tastebuds. I order the 2 eggs with sausage and homefries and extra bacon on the side. Nothing complicated. My one request please make the Homfries Crispy. That's big for me because carbs once in a blue is a treat for me and they need to be good. I got my food and the potatoes look and tast the same nasty. No seasoning no onions nothing crispy about it. It looks like boiled potatoes drained and tossed in grease No Abodo No Lawrys No Garlic Poweder nothing just tossed in grease. The eggs were okay the bacon was good I think they nuked the sausage. To each is own this is not a place I would goto again for breakfast or recommend.

Completely got my order wrong and although i said “a little” extra ketchup put so much on it was inedible! I had to waste 45 minutes of my day to go back and have them re make the order, i ordered an additional sandwich and also got a coffee! Instead of at bare minimum offering me the coffee they charged me and didn’t offer any sort of apology for their mistake! My 45 minutes is valuable to me and they didn’t care at all! Will never go back and i have eaten there 30 plus times at least! Very poor customer service

This was my 3rd time eating here! Love it I’ll most definitely be back soon.

A Gem ?Update: reason why I have to give this shop a dislike is solely on the basis of there lack of customer service! I send my boyfriend every single day to pick up my breakfast and they are always so lovely to him but anytime I come in I get attitude, they constantly give me a hard time. Since they are so selective on who they want to treat with the upmost professionalism we will no longer be coming here. Tips are unappreciated and honestly just not deserving I wish the cooks had a tip jar because my breakfast is always made with love ❤ when there's mix up they correct it with no problem but the ladies in the front?? Terrible. Maybe more training needs to be enforced. I'm not sure but Its just awful when most days I only have time for breakfast and I come in and their attitudes and demeanor just take away my appetite. The Food is great but I value customer service just as much. And that's where everything is lacking unfortunately.

Best place for deli sandwiches and salads. Good portions at a decent price

Placed an order online for pickup. Showed up on time to pick order but no order was made as they didn’t have it in their system. Order was placed through their website and I had an email confirmation. Because the order wasn’t ready on time, I was late for my train to the city. Person at the front desk is rude. Food is ok but with such a rude customer service and orders being missed, I would rather take my business elsewhere.