Magic 5 Pie Co.

230 East Ave, Norwalk - 06855
83 reviews
Pizza
(203) 354-3109

Great service, selection and good portions and food

Have gone there 4 times and really enjoyed. The 5th visit was not so magic, the waiter was confused and our order was not served together. Had to get the host to correct this.

Met a friend for dinner who had recently lost her husband. We needed a lot of time to talk. Staff was very generous about this.

Great pies Quite at lunch but cool vibe And nice friendly efficient service Definitely worth trying

Delicious pizza!!

We were visiting from Florida and needed a fix of new york style pizza. This was the best pizza we have had in a while. The crust was a little charred which was just perfect and the mozzarella was stringy as it should be. The sauce was light and sweet. Our waiter was responsive and our water glasses were always filled. Wasn’t crazy about the Brussel sprout Caesar, but would definitely come back next time we are in area.

Happily surprised by this at the time, unknown pizza restaurant. Have consistently found that their freshly prepared pizza. The whole pie was prepared with live, both the pie & crust delicious. We were blown away by the Clam Pie, Cheese Pie and Sausage & Onion Pie. Their Salads are also a treat, especially enjoy the Wedge of Lettuce with Homemade Dressing.Highly recommend trying this Terrific Pizza spot.

Hidden gem in Norwalk. Pizza is amazing and reminds me of the pizza I had in Napoli Italy. Of course Napoli is Napoli but Magic 5 Pie is pretty close.

Casual setting, interesting creative pizza combinations. Good wine & beer selection. Haven’t tried their curated mix drinks yet, but they look good walking by our table. Kind waitstaff. We’ve been 3 times, loved each meal, & intend to return soon.

My only complain is the booth seating - seats are low for the table, so difficult to get the pizza that comes on a very cool stand - so I would say not easy for shorter people like me :)