College Pizza

262 Pequot Ave, New London - 06320
36 reviews
Pizza Chicken Wings
(860) 574-9955

Ordered delivery, first time eating from here, when I called ,I asked for the tzatziki sauce on the side was put on and the gyro meat was dry and hard, did not enjoy it at all,extremely disappointed, didn't even really eat much, I had ordered 2 ,I said no tomatoes and there was some on one of them,had to pick them off... Will post pic later... That is burned and dry.... I was asked to send in an ema,did that and no response

First time ordering delivery from College Pizza- it was fast, accurate and delicious! Highly recommend!

I order from College pretty regular, the food is great and consistent and the staff is out of this world. But today I ordered a cheese pizza and let me tell you it was just about perfect. Making pizza is like making eggs, if you can’t do the basics perfect, you can’t do anything. This pizza today was a masterpiece, spot on cheese to sauce ratio, crust crispy, but with a great chew and expertly cooked. If you’re looking for some crazy, California inspired pizza with truffles and gold flakes, this isn’t the place for you. But great food, done right, by a friendly staff? College Pizza is a must try.

We always order delivery and no matter what we get they are always so fast! Food does not dissappint.

Whoever just picked up the phone was rude, also their menu isn’t accurate and you shouldn’t advertise what you don’t have

I have been ordering from this place all summer. It is like eating from my own kitchen. All of the ingredients are of high quality and perfectly prepared. The people are fantastic and prices are well worth it. I will miss this place when I leave for the Winter! Also, I challenge you to find a better burger and fries! I literally feel bad for the people I see standing in line at Freds.

I love good pizza and will pass up mediocre pizza. Staying nearby, i didn't know what to expect from this place but I was MORE than pleased with the quality and taste of this pizza. I will look forward to returning someday!

Epic burger! Epic fries! (Parker is a gentleman. I appreciate a great customer service.

The food tastes good, but . . . I ordered chicken tenders and picked Ranch as the sauce. I’ve never had it served this way. The chicken was in a container completely submerged in Ranch so it wasn’t crispy, but soggy. The menu should say Chicken Tenders IN Ranch Sauce.

The delivery was not correct. When I called the young lady that works there, she first falsified the order and I explained I do have a receipt and an email with the exact items I ordered. Of course here story changed!!! Then she told me I can come down to pick up the order. So I sent my son down, then she called and said we need to bring the mistake. I called to inform them of the inconvenience, she actually raised her voice and was arguing with me. I am the customer, you delivered the wrong items, I spent $85 after a tip and you are arguing???? I"m very confused. Not good for business!!!!!!