Tomatillo

320 Elm St, New Haven - 06511
151 reviews
Mexican Tex-Mex
(203) 782-6000

Very good straight forward Mexican. Beef was really good.

Such a friendly place! The guy who served me was so friendly and conversational. Everything that we got was so good. Everything was handmade and clearly with love. The prices are perfect for the quantity and quality of food we received. Can’t express enough how much of a hidden gem this is. I will definitely be returning over and over.

Food tasted okay Salim must’ve been off today? barley any meat plus couldn’t put the tortilla on top as I asked so it wouldn’t get soggy. Didn’t add napkins or forks, don’t add extras you won’t get much more

ME & MY HUSBAND REALLY ENJOYED THE FOOD TONIGHT..WE ARE STILL POPPING OUR GUMS..THANK YOU FOR YOUR GREAT SERVICE ??

I don't give out bad reviews if the food is bad , but the attitude and the care of the person who served me made me give a negative review.If you are someone who has not eaten Mexican food , I wouldn't suggest you to try here.I waited for 7 minutes for my enchiladas and asked the cashier if my order has been placed , I got a response " your food is in the oven , if you want it raw I can get it out raw , " I apologized and got interrupted with a " okokokok " and she was really rude.After I came home with my take out:I had asked them to make my dish spicy, got my dish (enchiladas) filled with spicy hot sauce, the person who served me straight-right lacks empathy she should have warned me that my dish is filled with hot sauce. Since my dish was takeout I couldn't do anything about it. Threw my dish to the trash, no way I can eat that.I don't think I see myself here again.

Ordered for lunch via Uber eats. I like that you can create your own tacos, burritos, bowls etc. Very simple and small menu that’s easy to follow. Pretty standard tasting tacos. Good value for your money.Fish tacos came with a generous portion of deep fried fish, however I found the taco was fairly dry. I think it might be because of the beans? But it would have been better if they had put more salsa

The food was okay going in and terrible coming out. I got food poisoning after getting a taco, burrito, and queso with chips. About 2 hours after finishing the food I felt incredibly ill. I was flushed and had diarrhea and was vomiting at the same time. Never eating from there again!!!!!

Wow great food!! Ordered from Uber eats as everything else was closed and how lucky did we get!! Ordered the nacho supreme with beef and they were fantastic, homemade chips w a hint of lime it had shredded beef so good! Ordered the shrimp tacos with beans and they were huge! got 3-4 small shrimps per taco but I could taste shrimp on every bite. Very happy with the food!

Great Service, great taco ???

Somebody recommended this place to me and so I had high hopes, but was disappointed. Really unfriendly staff. Nachos were horrible - definitely skip those. The tacos were okay but not authentic at all. If you’re going to eat here, maybe try the tacos or a bowl.