Katalina's

74 Whitney Ave, New Haven - 06510
108 reviews
Dessert
(203) 891-7998

I would give them 0 stars if possible. I am so beyond disappointed and upset. I ordered a cake for my mother's 50th birthday party and THIS was the writing they put on the cake. How could they be professionals and deem that acceptable and expect someone to be okay with paying for it. It looks like a child wrote it and it doesn't even fit properly on the cake. And the cake itself tasted like pure baking soda. We had to throw the cake out because it tasted terrible. The only good thing about this was the frosting. I will never order from them again.

I got a basic chocolate chip cookie. It was alright. It was pretty hard, which I suspected by the looks of it, but I didn't want to be rude and not buy anything after walking in. I bake a lot, so I know how to make soft/softer cookies. I'm just curious to know what their recipe is. Maybe the bigger cookies are causing a longer bake time, resulting in harder cookies. Maybe people just prefer them that way.I know this is a lot about one simple cookie lol, but I'm pregnant and had a craving, so I had high hopes. I was, however, very pleased to see gluten-free and vegan options. So that's a plus!

Ordered a spooky Victorian-themed sheet cake for my daughter's 18th birthday party, chocolate with lavender frosting...hauntingly delicious and glorious to behold as well!

I got one of their chocolate cupcakes with oreo cream frosting and it was OKI've had better cupcakes from a grocery store to be honest. The cake was crumbly, dry and tasted kind of like raw flour. The icing was way too sweet and basically tasted like powdered sugar. I probably wouldn't go back here again.The store itself is really cute though. Very "small town bakery" vibes!

I ordered vegan cupcakes for an event and they were a huge hit!! Thank you!!!

OMG, the mango mousse cake and mini cheesecakes are the best in town!!!

Gluten Free Carrot CakeFirst time trying Would not recommend gluten free carrot cake - not baked well tasted like oil, baking powder and raisins. Very dense and sticky. Way to many raisins/currants. Have 2 stars for effort.Haven’t tried other products at this bakery others reviews look good just not recommending this one.

It was a pleasure working with Katalina’s bakery! Cake was as expected and very yummy! We ordered a vegan chocolate cake with chocolate butter frosting.

Really good treats that are both hard to find flavors & yummy basic bakery gems like cookies & brownies

Katalinas icing is out of this world good. Her coffee cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes EVERYTHING are so flavorful baked from scratch and you can tell she puts her heart in everything she makes. I love the Hungarian options. Stop by and have the best bakery and coffee experience!