Newfield Pizza

558 Newfield St #4, Middletown - 06457
109 reviews
Pizza Italian
(860) 704-8244

These people are extremely rude. I ordered a hamburger and asked for lettuce and tomato. They said they couldn’t make it that way. I asked them to charge me for it. They said they just told me it doesn’t come that way. Then asked me “do you want it or not?” Sounds like other people had a horrible experience also. How they stay in business is beyond me. I hope they fold……soon.

Nothing to write home about. They give you a medium size pizza and call it a large...you get 8 small pieces which end up costing you $3.00 per piece. Very expensive. You know, they're playing the COVID SCAM, push up those prices! Most likely won't go there again. I wouldn't buy the grinders either, they don't put enough meat in there, just filler stuff with lots of bread. Oh well.

The owner is so nice! The pizza is always really good. The prices are so much more reasonable than other pizza shops in the nearby area. I’ve always had a pleasant experience with this establishment.

My husband and I order from Newfield Pizza maybe once a week or every other week (we have very busy days with kids activities) we’ve been eating here for 6 years! From dinners, Calzones, pizza and even party pizzas for birthday parties!! The food has always been consistently good, we’ve never had an issue in regards to delivery times (they are very honest about times during busy nights) Every single delivery driver has been very professional and kind! They know my husband by face and are so sweet to my girls, which goes to show how much they value their customers! You can tell they take pride in what they do and work hard to please the customer....That’s a hard trait to find these days!!

these people are true masters! it takes great skill to make pizza as cheap as mine was. I ordered a small hawaiian, for starters it arrived cold. the crust was thin as paper and hard as clay, there was such a tiny amount of sauce on it that it barely stained the crust. there was more exposed crust than there was toppings. I doubt there was even a tablespoons worth of cheese on it. there was maybe six pieces of pineapple and perhaps eight pieces of ham. absolutely the worst pizza I've ever had. I will never order from there again. I wish I had eaten in I would have sent it back to the kitchen.

The pizza is good in flavor and the price is just about average but the pie size is quite small.

Best pizza and hamburger I Love this place

Pizza sauce was canned and not enough cheese. Also very sweet tasting like they added sugar to it

Great food and service! Everyone who works here is so nice!

I had their Classic American Burger and it did not disappoint. Served on a toasted roll with tomato, cheese, and lettuce, it was absolutely delicious. The staff are also very kind. I will be coming back here again. I recommend.