GAROFALO'S PIZZA

3000 Whitney Ave, Hamden - 06518
99 reviews
Pizza Salad Burgers
(203) 288-3200

I ordered a large cheese pizza and they gave me old recycled pizza from one pie and added it to another pie to make 1 whole pie. They get one star only for the fact that they reimbursed me for the pizza and made me a new one and delivered it to me rather then me coming back and wasting my gas.

I ordered a Bacon ? Cheeseburger that was so deliciously mouthwatering and the French Fries were just as good, I called and reordered the same thing, but this time I got Carrot ? Cake ?, Mmmmmmmmm, the staff is very professional and polite, I hope that Connecticut Magazine votes them best overall Restaurant in our State, can't wait to order more of their delicious food, they have a loyal Customer for life with me, and I will always recommend them to friends and family, Magnifico.

I just miss the old place and owners the food was alot better. I used to get the philly cheesesteak pizza which was out of this world I've never tasted another like it. I don't normally write reviews and my purpose is not to bash whoever took over, But it shouldn't take 15 minutes to get a credit card number and take an order. At least put someone competent on the phone that knows what they're doing.

Delicious pizza delivered on time

Delicious food

something for everyone on our newly updated menu.

First off, I don’t ever write reviews. Nothing against the person working there but the order was completely wrong. Wanted mozzarella on the sub. No cheese at all. Three pieces of letuce, ONE strip of bacon. Also there is never someone working the front counter. I hope they see this to make improvements. Until then, this is not the place.

***Updated for Garofalo’s. Only ordered a meatball grinder, but it was really tasty. I enjoyed it. It was full of great tasting meatballs and lots of mozzarella. I felt that it was a good deal for less than $8 for a sub. Definitely looking forward to trying other items on their menu.

Excellent pizza..... good find. I was only in the area for business.

not satisfied. the garlic knots were raw on the inside and the pizza wasn't great.