Ice Cream was great and the young lady who took care of me was so very nice. Very nice experience...
Kudos to the one young guy working Mothers Day 2022 around 8pm all by himself with a huge line. He kept his cool making order after order and ringing out each patron; each shake takes over a minute made with care and each mix-in is hand turned. Then washing the board by hand in between. All the while being calm, cool, and professional. Even having to run down in the cellar to grab more shake cups in the middle of this stress. I felt awful when I thought I ordered something simple like a sundae only to see him have to stop to whip a new batch of whipped cream. I hate the cheapskate customer bald guy who prob drives a Mercedes’ in front of us who spent $16, hands him a $20 and leaves a lousy $1 tip when you see how hard this kid was working. You suck. Hope you spent that extra $2 you kept for yourself on something you don’t deserve. Worth the wait as always.
I've been going to Timothy's for years! Always fantastic ice cream, they've been doing smush ins for like, 40+ years, but you don't need it as all the flavors are great, along with the in-house waffle cones. Worth a trip if you're in the area!
I'm not going back. Very nice staff.
One of my favorite places for a classic cream Sunday!
This place is not what I was expecting when I entered and it wasn't what I was expecting when I left. However, they had some of the best ice cream I have ever had. The staff was friendly and they made my ice cream to perfection (they mix the ice cream similar to Cold Stone, but better). I will be back in the near future!
good ice cream open late. try the milk shakes.
Very friendly service and delicious ice cream
The chocolate ice cream was good but you might as well get large for a Dollar 25 more because the small is the smallest small ever, practically a thimble for 3.25.
Very pleasant old fashioned ice cream shop. They have a real antique ice cream machine in the front window, plenty of welcoming kitschy ice cream themed decor, and the young men running the counter were friendly. The ice cream itself was quite good, but the homemade waffle cones and bowls were the best, with great crispy texture and plenty of flavor.