Anthony's used to be the place I would refer people if they wanted excellent NY pizza. The last couple times the cheese sticks didn't taste great, so I stopped ordering those. Now, even the pizza is disappointing - prices went up but quality went down. A 1-topping pizza (well, I only wanted half but have to pay for full) pickup, including tax and modest $3 tip - $34. For ONE pie of pizza. And it wasn't even great. A $34 people should have me doing backflips. Very disappointed, not too keen on giving them a chance at redemption at $34 a pie. Time to find a new pizza spot.
What else can you say great pizza ? the whole menu is great I will always stop by Anthony's to have a great slice of pizza
Biggest waste of $50 ever. Order totally wrong. Over $25 dollars for a cheese pizza????? Who do they think they are?Sadly Domino's is a better choice.
In my opinion, the best New York style pizza in the area. Good crust, and if you like it more crunchy just ask for extra crispy and they will cook it longer. Good sauce and lots of cheese. When you fold the slice, as you should, the oil drips off the back of the slice. Just like in New York. Best if you order an entire pizza and get it fresh out of the oven. Never a disappointment at Anthony's
My wife put in an online order at 5:00 pm, to be delivered at 7:00 pm. Our order did not arrive until 8:01 pm. This was after not one, but two calls to the store to check the status of our order. We asked the head front desk person to discount our order (the manager is apparently not working and apparently no assistant manager) but they would not do so. I think my nine year old summed it up best “should’ve just gotten Black Jack.” Indeed we should have and so should you…
Ordered cheese sticks with my meal. They arrived, cold wet and soggy. I am pretty sure they threw them in the microwave. Do not order the cheese sticks. I wish I could get a refund.
This pizza at Anthony's pizza is ATROCIOUS!! Dont waste ur money! New york would be so offended!! Totinos .88 cent pizza is WAY better! I'm so surpised they r still open! & they r the same price as dominos now.. but not worth 1cent! Wish i wouldve just pick up a pizza from Walter's or Domino's.
Pizza is good but have ordered there a couple of times and always forget to bring entire order. The wait is long so when they forget it ruins your plans. Have called and manger told me they would credit my account for missing items. Never happened. When I call they say call back when it is not our rush. Really want to like this place but just can’t keep getting ripped off.
Honestly it's the closest you'll let to a NY pizzeria without actually going to NY. Born dn raised there 22 years and honestly coming here is like a little slice of home for me. I see a lot of complaints about the pizza being greasy and yea it's a little greasy but that's just kinda how it is and if you've been to NY you know the oil dripping off the back is par for the course. I genuinely don't understand the low rating but they get 5 stars from me and I'll be back frequently. Great pepperoni slices, that's my go to order always.
Place is clean fast service i remember the pizza being so much better