My Favorite Muffin

12201 E Arapahoe Rd, Centennial - 80112
146 reviews
Sandwich Shop Bagels
(303) 799-8931

We were a bit surprised at this location. Lots of yummy muffin options in different sizes, and lots of bagel, egg & sandwich options too. Nice sized dining area, and a much bigger shop than what we anticipated.But, the lady helping me didn’t speak English so she didn’t answer my questions & wasn’t helpful in the slightest. So important to have employees that help customers speak English. They made us a latte instead of a cappuccino. And they threw our mini muffins into a box, some got squished. This place has potential & the food was great, but the staff needs improvement.

These folks really have breakfast figured out. My coffee was just right, and the chocolate muffins can justify a trip to Centennial! THANKS!

Reasonably priced mini, medium, and large sized muffins. The deep dish apple muffin and strawberry banana smoothie were delicious! They also have assorted bagels as well as bagel chips. Customer service was great, and ambiance is warm and cozy. I can't wait to try all the muffin flavors.

Been frequenting My Favorite Muffin for 8 or 9 years now and it's one of those places you just crave. The Breakfast Ranchero has been my go to since day one. The mini muffins can't be beat. We love the cinnamon crumb, chocolate chip and lemon.

Had a really nice conversation with the owner this morning. Really good person. My breakfast sandy was really good. I'll definitely be back as this place is right by my new place of work.

A hidden gem for sure! I'm normally not a huge baked goods lover buy these muffins are on another level! Giant, fluffy, moist, and creative and traditional flavors. The breakfast sandwiches and lattes are amazing too, I can't wait to take a big box of these muffins to my coworkers!

Not only do they have the most amazing muffins, I showed up 5 minutes after closing and they were not only nice enough to let me grab a few, they let me have them for free! Amazing place, will definitely be back!

This place is amazing. I usually always order large orders for my work on holidays and they never fail to make that happen. The owner (who I think is the owner) is so humble and sweet! So happy to support they’re business!!!!

Great staff and customer service. Very clean .Fresh muffins and bagels and sandwiches made there. They differently have my business wkly.

Great muffins! Very disappointed with the coffee. The two kinds I would have chosen were out. I took decaf Columbian, was luke warm at best. They do have bagels and breakfast sandwiches.