Mary's Pizza Shack

535 Summerfield Rd, Santa Rosa - 95405
231 reviews
Pizza Italian
(707) 538-1888

Got pizza and chicken fettuccine Alfredo and the pizza was okay but the pasta was disappointing. The chicken was pretty dry and the pasta and sauce were just okay. Honestly the small portion too wasn't worth the price either. The staff are friendly at times but this time were just okay. Mary's is generally good and love the localness of it but wish it was better especially for the price and name.

First time here. Really nice place. Pizza was pretty good.

Good pizza place. Made the mistake of getting pizza 30 minutes before they closed and pizza was not great. Ordered at lunch time from a different location a few days later and pizza was much better.

Was there for a B-day party. Food was good however it didn't all arrive at or near the same time and one order was wrong.

Thought would order a nice pizza to enjoy the Niner game. ?Called around 5:10pm asked for delivery by 6:30pm. Had asked for Extra sausage, with 3 other ingredients. Hardly ANY Sausage Had to call at 6:45pm to check.Finally got around 7. Thin crust, (not ordered), hardly any sauce or cheese.Over $50 for worst than Little Ceasars.Very, VERY disappointed. Mary's used to have great food and service

I was very impressed by the level of hospitality and service from the staff and management. Combined with top notch cusine and beautiful indoor and outdoor dining areas this is my favorite joint in town.

Visited here with family, I am from Texas so I had never been. The first impression was it has a great atmosphere, yet not so friendly staff. As we entered we were told by a woman they would see if they could accommodate us. Our group was 14. So I understand. The service how ever was not good at all. Drinks were empty for long periods of time, our server wasn't insight to offer assistance. We had to ask other servers for help. The food came out in shifts and the kids food was last to hit the table. With kids at the table they should always get their food first in my opinion due to the fact they are hungry and get antsy when waiting. When the food arrived my pasta was extremely dry. The pizzas looked very good but seemed to take so long to get the kids ended up taking them home instead of being able to eat it there. Several times I just wanted to get up and go grab the drink pitcher myself and refill glasses throughout the entire restaurant. Overall I was not impressed with anything other then the atmosphere and visiting family.

This place used to be great. I have probably been here 50+ times. Every time I have been in 2021 the food has been lackluster, service severely lacking, and the wait time ridiculously long. I don't know how you get my order to me half an hour later than when I ordered for pick up and it tastes worse than costco pizza for more than twice the price. No plates, napkins, utensils, parmesan, or peppers. The individual even forgot my salad and dressing before I reminded them. I have no idea what has happened to staffing here but treatment from staff resembles an experience closer to fast food than a family dinning experience.

Showed up for to go order on time and paid, only to find out my pizzas had not been started.......funny, the guy in front of me had same problem. He took a credit back and left the restaurant. Also, the plexiglass and masks make it impossible to hear the cashier. Watching the feeble efforts to enforce mask policy including those behind the plexiglass dropping the mask to yell across the room comical. Mary’s has good food but I won’t be back for a long time and until Management gets it together. Dump the plexiglass and the masks and tell the State to stuff it! Ridiculous!

Mary's is a great place to go, It started out as a local Sonoma County restaurant. They now have 19 restaurants but only in northern California area. Some of my favorites are the fresco pesto breadsticks, Bruschetta, Either flavor of the chicken wings, Penne with Italian sausage pasta. The chicken or beef protein plate is great if you're watching your carbs, I always ask for extra mushrooms. The Mary's Signature salad is well known for all the toppings, the large salad is big enough to share. I love the homemade blue cheese salad dressing. The pizzas are great too! They have a great reasonably priced happy hour also. This restaurant is a must especially if you're from out of town.