Mountain Mike's Pizza

1729 N Broadway, Santa Maria - 93454
141 reviews
Pizza
(805) 862-2400

Very pleasant atmosphere pizza pretty good service ?

Got a small pineapple chicken luau pizza. This was amazing! Pineapple, grilled chicken, bacon, and bbq sauce. Also got a side salad which was basic but good. Manager was very nice. Will order again!

Ordered a small pizza and salad to go. Still waiting over 1 hour. They have plenty of bodies working but no management what so ever in the kitchen.

Bad service. The restrooms were dirty and smelly. Customer service was not very good, we waited for an 1hr just for them to tell us they ran out of Jalapeños Poppers. Alot of people waiting for their food over 40 minutes

Nice, pizza was average, but good for delivery type pizza.

Best pizza I have had in years

we ordered and the food was terrible..it came way late and cold. when we called all we got was sorry ill speak to the driver.

Mountain Mike's Pizza has the Freshest ingredients, Reasonable and Great Quality!!! You have to try the All-You-Can eat Pizza and Salad Bar for lunch M-F 11-2pm for $9!!!

We ordered a Lg. Mt. Veggiemore and substituted the tomato's for pepperoni. Overall the Pizza had an excellent smoky flavor, however, the crust was so thick that the dough never cooked past 1" of the crust, it is not safe to eat uncooked dough, I actually was nauseous from it. The green peppers were cut way too big, overtook the pie.Maybe it's preference but we also felt it needed more pizza sauce.That being said, if we ordered it again, would have to go like this: Mt. Veggiemore, substitute tomatos for pepperoni, thinner crust (not an option), much smaller pieces of peppers or none at all, and extra sauce. Now consider the substitution of pepperoni for tomato raised the price by $3.00 ????? I could have gotten an all meat for the same price! Add $5.00 coupon, should be $21.75 + tax 1.58 = $23.33, If I eliminate an item, such as the green peppers do I get an additional $3.00 off, considering it was added when substituting? We paid $27.18We stopped going to Pizza Hut because of uncooked pizza dough.We live just a stones throw from your store and only just tried it now because others have said similar things, the price, too thick......Your ad claims the best pizza in Santa Maria, you have heavy competition out there, Blaze, LaVera, Klondike, etc.Santa Maria is finicky .....just saying!

Fantastic pizza, absolute worst timing in the history of pizza shops. They clearly don’t know what an hour means. If you’re hungry for dinner, order it at lunch just to be safe.