Tin Pot Creamery

3081 S Delaware St B, San Mateo - 94403
318 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream
(650) 458-3171

They don’t allow you to split flavors in a single scoop so not a good place for those who don’t want too much ice cream of the same flavor. We’ve been here a handful of times and the last few visits, our ice cream was melting even before we checked out to pay. It almost feels like the freezer isn’t strong enough (?) anymore so the ice cream is not an ice cream but more of a shake 2 minutes in.Service was definitely not the friendliest on a Sunday afternoon. I will probably skip next time and just stick to blue bottle next door or travel to yumi yogurt.

Tried this place for the first time and loved their ice cream texture and flavors! They’ve really unique flavors - I tried something with Jasmine and another with Coconut (very tropical) and I loved it! They also have the standard flavors and they’ve the perfect smoothness and balance of flavors.

Cute little ice cream place with some standard flavors and some more unique and interesting flavors! I went with some friends and I liked pretty much every flavor that we got. Price wise seemed pretty standard for a nicer ice cream spot.

Good choice of seasonal + regular flavors and best waffle cones!All time favs include the salted butterscotch and chocolate

Great ice cream, but when I asked for an extra cup to split the order with my daughter standing with me, one of the employees actually told the other to stop and charge for another separate order. Alas, I love their ice cream, but disappointed that their corporate policy has changed to nickel and dime.

Last year, I came across a post about their well-known Blue Jasmine Tea ice cream, and ever since, it's been running on my mind. I finally made the trip to go try it. Creamy and light hints of floral jasmine. Almost too pretty to eat! I liked it, but I had better. Wish it had a little more jasmine flavor to it.

Delicious as always

Kids love the Cookie Monster ice cream ! If you have little ones you should bring here , to enjoy it .

Great ice cream. Woeth the visit.

blue jasmine flavor was floral and not bad, but also a little overpowering... like i got tired of it after a few bites. would like to try some other flavors in the future. also small chunks of ice in the ice cream, not as creamy as i expected. nice area though with lots of outdoor seating.