Came here because of the reviews and high rating. Ordered a Hawaiian pizza. Unfortunately the quality of the pizza does not match the hype. The crust feels like overcooked, deep fried, unproofed dough and the sauce and toppings on the greasy salty side. Sad to say I was disappointed that many people found this to be the best pizza in the area. I think I’ve had better dominoes pizza.
Photos
Menus
Best thin crust pizza hands-down! My family has been eating here for decades, back at the original location and owner.
I remember this place at the old location with the old man. I grew up eating here and have been back a few times now that I’m not in the area anymore.Last time I took some friends to have the “best pizza ever” and it sucked. The sauce had very little taste like someone forgot the spices. The pizza soaked the entire cardboard box with grease, by the time we got the pie open to eat, 10 mins, the bottoms of all the slices were soaked with grease and soggy.I guess this place went the way of everything else, diminishing quality to make a faster buck. IDK hope it gets better because I had great memories eating there.
Yummy ? We have been coming here for years! Very casual. Very popular in the neighborhood ?
Well baked, crispy thin crust...amazing! Only reason for 4 stars and not 5 is that the crust was SUPER oily during our most recent take out visit (only experienced this once).
Still so good after all these years. Pizza was ready when promised and their new window set up in the front makes it’s so easy to pickup during Covid.
I have had a lot of pizza in my life at this point. Yet, in my humble opinion, nobody on the planet has matched the absolute perfection of the Spicy Vegetarian. My family and I have been returning to Cicero's for decades now, and I certainly plan to continue that trend.
What I liked best about this restaurant was its excellent menus. When we returned, we were stuffed. All of their dishes are wonderful. They're all delectable! You will have a fantastic time here! This is excellent for entertaining family and friends. This is also appropriate for romantic outings. It's amazing!
CRAVING SATISFACTION! I was craving spaghetti and pizza, and thankfully, this place was close by. They were in charge of giving me with a great pizza and a really tasty spaghetti that satisfied my needs. They provided truly outstanding services, and their rates are quite reasonable. Thank you a million times over! You guys are amazing!
Wow just wow. What a great Pizza. This is one of the best Pizza I've eaten in Bay Area so far.The crust was perfect and by looks it wins hands down.It is a 9.1 Pizza! You're missing out if you haven't tried this one.