This place has awesome pizzas that are super cheesy. The portions are quite big so be careful when ordering! I was in a group of three, and a half Caesar, garlic bread, and medium cheese pizza was more than enough. Make sure to give the pizza a few minutes to cool otherwise the cheese will slip right off.The place gets packed so make sure you grab a table when you can!
Bbk chk pizza had no onions on it and very light sauce could not eat it. I love pizza, so does my family but a couple nights ago we despised it. I ordered half bbk chk half chz so my family could split a $40 dollar pizza, 1 pizza, just to get home and nobody would eat it. Chk was dry, just chk and bbk sauce definitely needs something else on it besides chz. Please replace the pizza I bought and my family could not eat thank u!
The pizza here at Gay nineties is always really good. Their sauce has a good flavor and their pizza always comes out hot (love the crust).I ordered the meatball sandwich which I wasn't very impressed with the meatballs didn't have much flavor or seasoning. The salad was very good and the Antipasto plate was huge and beautifully put together.
Service was okay...let me explain, when guests are seated you should drop off the drink menu with the food menu. Also, due to the fact we had our appetizer bought and left without napkins, utensils or plates. My wife got up and set out to find and bring them back with her. Now he (our server) was very polite and attentive which I appreciate.The pizza was a B- due to a little bit of liquid pooling in the middle under the center making it a little soggy.The ingredients were fresh. We tried a half pepperoni with BBQ chicken as well as a Frank's Special (no mushrooms) not a fan of fungus.
Heard great reviews about the pizza me and my fiance went out to go eat. Went on a Saturday evening around 5:30 PM. Waited at the front door, finally had to go get somebody to come seat us. Sat down had to wait 15 minutes and still nobody came to offer us drinks or to take our order. I completely understand with a pandemic and shortage of employees but this was unacceptable. The unexperienced, unprofessional with no hospitality skills waiter said he'd bring someone out but never did and when I questioned him he got an attitude and was very Rude. Unfortunately we left and we never got to taste the food. Because of the service that we got I will never try their food and never go back there again unfortunately.
The young couple that owns and runs this place is a pleasure to do business with. The pizza is excellent and consistent. Quality food. Love this place. They appreciate your business here.
We absolutely love our favorite eatery. Growing up in our hometown Pleasanton Gay 90’s is a must go to place for a wonderful meal. Delicious pizza and a wonderful service. ❤️
Been coming here since I was a small child with my Dad, decades later it reasons delicious. Make sure to order their house dressing with the salad.
The pizza was great . We went around 6pm on a sat night and it was busy . A longer wait time for the pizza ? but the pizza was delicious. I was not happy about the flower person coming to our table inside asking us to buy flowers while we waa eating .
Nice vibe to this place. Has outdoor seating on the patio as well. Really good pizza. Really enjoyed it.