Amazing. You know the food is good when you're willing to drive in traffic to pick it up.They have authentic Chicago style pizza, with fresh ingredients that you can tell they put effort and heart into every pie.The Sicilian style is equally amazing.Their entire pizza menu is unique with so many different and amazing choices. And did I mention the cannoli? So good you won't want to share!A family owner mom and pop pizza place with amazing flavorful pizzas! The owners can tell they truly enjoy making your meal great! Highly recommend and hoping one day they open a second store in Marin *fingers crossed*Thank you for an another amazing dinner!
I ordered the mad Sicilian for dinner. A half and half Sicilian pizza, bread sticks and the rhubarb cannolis. I actually ordered the tiramisu but they were out of stock so they called to let me know and asked what I would prefer to replace with. Very quick with only a 30 minute wait for delivery. Pizza was fluffy and crunchy. Sauce was good. I felt it was missing a little zest or that little oomph. But none the less it was good! I will be ordering again!
By far the best pizza in Petaluma, both regular crust and deep dish. I was amazed to find a place that can cook deep dish pizza identical to my favorite pizzeria in Chicago. Also, the monthly special pizzas are a great way to try unusual toppings you've never had before
This place not only has amazing pizza but it also has heart. Just watch them make the food, you can see the pride that goes into every dish. They are in business because they have something to offer to the community not just to make a buck. You want to walk into a place and feel like family and eat some great food then try The Mad Sicilian, you can thank me later.
My husband and I just went for the first time 3 days ago, today we called after dinner just for two orders of breadsticks. The pizza? Bomb dot com. The ranch? Best Ive ever had, if they sold it by the gallon. I’d be first in line. The crust? A beautiful symphony of garlic and Parmesan that greets you how you imagine your grandma would. You can taste the love they put into the food as well as the respect for the ingredients. Their food is delicious and filling without giving you that feeling that you’ve just eaten a greasy piece of cardboard like some other pizza does. The only place we will be going to from now on.
Everything my tastebuds needed! Packed with flavor. Highly recommend!
A decent pizza place, we visited here on a Sunday evening and the place wasn’t busy at all. We ordered the Syracuse pizza and the size was good, apt for a medium pizza. The roasted garlic and red pepper toppings were great too.However the chicken on the pizza just seemed boiled and tasteless. We were expecting some spice or taste in the chicken. The cannolis tasted scrumptious, we liked that they weren’t too sweet. The service was prompt and polite with the staff checking in on us throughout our time here. They’ve parking outside as well.I’ll be back here to try the other pizzas. Overall a decent family run place that dishes out good pizzas and other Italian items.
We decided to eat here after we saw a few highly rated yelp reviews and oh my they didn't disappoint! All my cheesey dreams came true! The tomatoes sauce on top was perfectly balanced! Don't forget to add roasted garlic! The hunky Sicilian man herd my cry when I realized I could have added some to my pizza and added it anyway ?? definitely a must! Do yourself a favor and eat here for dinner
Call in and get the Mad Greek. You won't regret it! Their deep dish is quite good as well and we also like their Sicilian style. The variety is great for families. One of our favorite places to eat in town!
Call the Old Chicago delivery number, and got a Mad Sicilian.Damn good pizza, check it out, you’re welcome