Old Chicago Pizza Restaurant

41 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma - 94952
247 reviews
Pizza Wine Bar Beer Bar
(707) 763-3897

awesome service ... killer pizza as usual♡

Good salad (though I wish they would put it in bowls), delicious pizza and the best garlic bread I’ve ever had.The staff is nice, in my experience, and the place has a wonderful old-timey industrial atmosphere.

Best local pizza ? placeUsually get cheese ? or veggiePretty good garlic bread ? too

If only there were more than five stars...

We ordered a medium deep dish with select toppings including olives and sausage. I lived in Chicago for 6 years off and on and given how rich a deep dish pizza can be, I'm used to having some sauce on the pizza. I didn't place the order so not sure if that was an option, but I think it could have helped temper the flavor on the olives. Olives were more like a tapenade and I couldn't taste the flavors of the other ingredients. So if you like olives, then you'll definitely like this place. Crust was flaky and really quite divine. I would go again but order something without olives and see if the balance of topping flavors are better. Salad was just meh. I wouldn't bother again but some vegetables were needed to cleanse the palate.

Just got back from Chicago and the deep dish didn’t even come close. Old Chicago is the best!

Deep dish pizza was fresh and good. Service was good also. Upstairs so be ready to climb.

What is better than pizza and beer! Delicious very much Chicago style. Restaurant has a unique feel and decore being in an older office building.

I’ve been to chicago and had the famous places stuff and honestly I liked this better. Amazing flavor with fantastic crust. I very much like this pizza and it was totally worth the price. Get lots of toppings, they don’t skimp.

This place is incredible