Woman who claimed to be the owner was sarcastic, rude, unapologetic, mocking, condescending, and repeatedly talked over me. Doesn't matter what the food is like if the owner is a terrible person.
Fantastic food. Large portions
In my opinion the New Yorker has the best pizza in town
The pesto parmesan bread sticks are amazing! Could've made a meal of just those. The pizza was also delicious. Great service too.
best pizza in Petaluma hands down
great pizza, but bad customer service. this girl with blond hair was not having it and the vibes were off
Pizza was delicious service could have been a little better.
Great neighborhood pizza place and decent salads. The service is fantastic.
I moved from Petaluma to the east coast 6 years ago and I always thought I loved pizza. Turns out I actually hate pizza and I just like New Yorker. New Yorker pizza somehow tastes differently than every other pizza on earth. I dream about it. The only reason id give them less than five stars is because they have ruined all other pizzas for me which has made ordering takeout in Pennsylvania severely limiting.
As a New Yorker this is the closest I have had to New York City pizza outside of Manhattan. Highly recommend.