Colosseum New York Pizza

761 E Capitol Ave, Milpitas - 95035
248 reviews
Pizza Cheesesteaks
(408) 262-8633

Best pizza , but no dine in or beer ! I'm sad ? good margarita pizza tho

Best pizza since I've been to New York! Hands down!Highly recommended. Very delicious.

Pretty good puzza and you can get them by the slice. The owner is a pretty.nice guy. You can also get fries and wings. Not a good place to hang out

Friday night I stopped by. I do think I was talking to the owner and we hit it off because he remembers way back when as he used to come here. I remember coming here as a kid back in the 70s' and '80s. Pizza was so delicious. I'm glad it's still here although the owners have changed. I ordered a cheese and pepperoni and it was superior. It really hasn't changed in my opinion which definitely brought me back to my childhood. Apparently I think they only take cash though because they wouldn't take a credit or debit card. I was a dollar short and the gentleman I talked to spotted me the dollar. As nice as they were over there I will be coming back before I leave back to Portland. Not just for the delicious pizza, but to also pay back the dollar and leave a tip.

A really good spot especially for New York fans. I came here a couple of times with my father to catch the Yankees playoffs here. I ordered the all meat pizza as usual. It's overall good, but it can have too much garlic for me on their pizzas with a lot of grease. I still go here just for the atmosphere of sports. A lot of parking but limited dining tables.

Can tell the folks working there are still the original owners, their photos from years ago are still on the walls. Great pizza.

The combo pizza is yummy with my budwieser.... they will accommodate ur request if u want customized pizza as well. ??

Good pizza ?

Pretty good pizza, got the garlic knots too and they were super garlicky (in a good way. I loved it) . Price was good, and in general I liked the vibe of the workers, nice people.

Love this place. Only reason not 5 stars is because they don't have wings or chicken parm that is on the menue.