Pizza Pronto

7556 Fay Ave, La Jolla - 92037
157 reviews
Italian Pizza
(858) 459-9000

Ordered a cheese pizza with pepperoni online, and when I showed up the cashier said they messed up and accidentally made a calzone instead. He asked if I wanted the calzone, and I said no thanks, just the pizza. They were very apologetic, and asked me to wait another 10 minutes for them to make the correct order. And I gotta say, I am so glad I decided to wait and not cancel the order. 5 stars even though they messed up!! Because this pizza was worth the wait and worth every penny!!! ?

The staff was so nice, and the food was great. I've been traveling and haven't been able to practice piano, but they let me riff on the restaurant one. Great spot.

So glad we found this place! It was just this small little Italian place with great reviews, so we decided to give it a try! I am VERY picky about my Italian dishes, including pizza! I'm full Italian, and from New York, so I'm used to great food. This place checked off all the boxes. Great menu, great calzones and the pizza was really good! Service was very friendly and food came out fast and perfect! I head down to La Jolla for work every couple of weeks and this is where I'll grab food every time!

Best pizza in San Diego absolutely love it ?

This is my favorite restaurant! I went there with my family and they were super nice! Since we loved their pizza, (they make their own pizza dough) I bought few to make it at home. I also asked how they make their dough but wouldn’t tell us since they make it all from scratch

Yummy ? food! Pasta, Salad and pizza all very delicious. Great friendly service! Definitely will be back! Not too busy on Wednesday night.

I guess we were out of luck. Salad ingredients were stale, pizzas were made with grocery-store frozen crust (not the italian airy kind!), and the fried calamary alike. Poor quality food and slow service.

Flavorful pizza - almost deep-dish. High-quality cheese & tomato sauce. Great outdoor patio area. Good gluten-free crust (which is hard to find).

Decent taste, not-so-decent texture

Such a quaint little restaurant! It’s a little hidden and out if the way but run by such friendly people! The food was amazing! My mom was a little iffy on the salad, but my ravioli was delicious! I will definitely be coming back!