New York Pizza Department & Bagels

2279 Eagle Glen Pkwy #105, Corona - 92883
487 reviews
Pizza Sicilian
(951) 493-6789

Well this place was definitely a huge disappointment! Ordered two different pizza to go. They wouldn’t take our older currency, then they shorted us change. Then we were told pizzas would be done in 45 minutes.We should’ve walked out at this point.but we didn’t ! So we sat in the restaurant waiting, we looked around at the TVs and the decorative items and it made us think. When does a business owner stop caring about their dream!This place should be ashamed, everything is so dusty and dirty “thick dust” filthy, unkept, given up so called restaurant! The bagel case filled with dust bunnies and then some. I’m smh still, I didn’t even want to use the restroom in fear of what’s going on in there! Then we saw people that ordered after us getting their pizzas!!! Well shocking our pizzas where’s done sitting on the counter we never got called! Ugh!I read other reviews and I’m guess people have lowered their standards or simply have no clue what real Italian food is! This food is subpar, no flavor and weak toppings. I will say this, the dough seems to be ok. With that said it’s not enough to bring us back. Find a better place to spend your hard earned money because I’m sure this place doesn’t care if you come back.You should be ashamed to call yourself Italian!

Wow! My lunch was enough food for 3 meals! Apparently I wasn't clear when I requested my pasta served on a separate plate with no sauce, because the pasta was served in lemon sauce as well and there was a pool of lemon sauce on the plate. I had to go back and request that they drain the pasta. Other than that, the service was friendly, and I'm sure I will visit again next time I'm in Corona.

Hit and miss after 1 visit. The service was friendly but there was room for improvement. The chicken parmesan was plentiful but uninteresting. And for $19 for the plate, I was slightly surprised to be served parmesan cheese in packets. The pizza was good, and the Buffalo wings were nice and crispy, but a $15 order comes with 8 pieces, which is slightly disappointing. The salad was large, fresh, and crisp, but I had to ask for a bowl to eat it on because the service plate was too small for the portion. At time of ordering, we asked for a pizza to go, in addition to our table-service items, but the server forgot to put in the to-go portion of the order, causing us to have to wait an extra 15 minutes, which isn't the end of the world, but then he (very obviously) lied to us about it. I mean, I don't expect anyone to be perfect, but don't BS me. The parking lot is accessible, with van parking and ramps, and the restaurant is a little cramped for a wheelchair, but would accommodate one. There was enough potential here that I'll give them another try, but there was definitely room for improvement on this visit.

My wife and I ordered baked stuffed shells from here on 5/27/22. I can only compare this to low grade dog food! The Marinara sauce was runny and tasteless, there was hardly any Mozzarella cheese on it. I honestly think it was frozen then microwaved to reheat. Their online menu has stuff shells for $14.95 we paid $16.95. I was extremely disappointed. And to ad insult to injury, the staff was very rude and unpleasant. When I called to complain, the manager Joe was Conveniently gone for the day. I only give one star, because Im unable to give less! Do yourself a favor and eat elsewhere.

Part of an amazing trio of restaurants on this corner and easier to get I to then the other 2. You will get a delicious pizza and some amazing salads and leave their full and satisfied.

This place is so tasty! I’m very picky of my pizza and usually prefer making it myself instead since I’m often disappointed eating it out. But I can say without a doubt this is the best pizza I’ve bought in a long time! The toppings are quality, creative, plentiful, and evenly dispersed. And the crust is even good enough to eat (I usually don’t eat many crusts!) We got the Athena pizza. I will definitely be back to try more pizzas.

Delfina pizza is delicious and consistent. Salsiccia pizza is a must and the saffron arancini is sooooo good. Absolutely recommend stopping here for a bite.

Good pizza, a little bit expensive but they’re super generous with their toppings and have good service.

Delicious pizza. I got the grand margherita with chicken and extra jalapeños. Sooooo bomb. Will come back and take pictures another day!

Two visits and two disappointments. Tried the white sauce as well as the regular pepperoni and couldnt even finish the pizza. When even a 5 year turns down the pizza it should have you second guess things. I went off some good reviews and word of mouth but all of those were outdated and I think this place isn't living up to what it once was