Nick The Greek

20628 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley - 94546
63 reviews
Greek Salad Soup
(510) 901-7107

I have to say I’ve been eating here sometimes over 5 times a week for that last few months but that stops today. I ordered online and went in to pick up my food and didn’t realize until I got home that the fries were gummy/under cooked. I usually would not return them but they were basically inedible. When I tried to exchange them a woman that looks like maybe the manager as I’ve never seen her there before proceeded to question me and feel through the French fries as if I was lying and then told the cook to make them well done. I didn’t ask for well done just that they were cooked. I feel this was condescending especially since when I opened them the fries were now unsalted and OVERCOOKED aka hard as a rock. Seems small but how you treat your customers matters. Will not return.

The gyro bowl was delicious. We got the lamb/beef. The sauce, rice, meat were all very flavourful. Definitely would come back again and maybe get the same dish or try the falafel.

Great tasting good and great service. We got a gyro bowl with beef/lamb and enjoyed it. The food was ready in only about 3 minutes. There's outdoor seating.

It’s ok. It’s pretty expensive for what it is. Tastes pretty ok. The gyro meat is super salty, the chicken kabob is small and dry. The Greek salad is good. Not a fan of french fries in a gyro. Wish we had a Troy or independent Greek restaurant instead. It’s “Greek” expensive fast food.

I didn't care too much for the meal but I would definitely give the cashier (female) 5 stars. She answered all my questions. She was knowledgeable concerning the menu. She was courteous and friendly.

Here is the way Gyro Plate (Beef, lamb )Gyro looks like. High price is expected because the area is beautiful. The plate was decorated nicely but after eating it , i was not impressed. It might be healthy, but the taste is average. And, i do not know if the food supposed to be hot or cold. It was slightly warm. That might be the reason why it was not as tasty as it could be. There will be nothing to remember about their food the next day. It is very nice inside the restaurant and employees are very helpful. I think this restaurant is a little bit overrated. I never tip until i finished eating the food and sit for awhile in the restaurant's environment to see if i really like it.

got the chicken gyro and loved it. bit overpriced but makes sense since prices are raising due to the pandemic, so it was nice to support a local business as well...

Not authentic given they put french fries in the Gyro but it's pretty darn good. Technically, potatoes and tomatoes for that matter are from the Americas.I'm still looking to replace my Gyro place that closed that I would have given 5 stars but this one is nearby and pleases my taste buds.First is having the right meat and then it's tzatziki sauce. The other ingredients can vary. Lettuce and onion with the Asian influence of onions and the American influence of tomatoes (and potatoes). In this regard, potatoes fit as an influence from the same region as tomatoes for more traditional builds.The thing that does keep me looking, is a little on the tzatziki sauce and some on the side salad which missed the mark.Overall, I'll be visiting many times in the future.

This is the WORST restaurant That I have ever eaten. If I could give 0 starts I would.We paid $10, for the sandwich. We asked for fries on the side. It came with 3 pinky size pieces. THREE. Ten dollars for three pieces of fries. We went back and everyone person that was working were very rude. The manager was Rudest. He was saying “Bye and leave”. I am going to laugh the day he gets fired from his job. Then I will say bye to him.

Clean establishment, family friendly, excellent Greek food. You have to check them out. We're blessed to have them in town