Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Castro Valley

20674 Rustic Dr, Castro Valley - 94546
205 reviews
Sandwich Shop Salad Soup
(510) 398-8532

I'm obsessed with the Tommy Turkey on Dutch crunch! The Dutch crunch is incredible and they should sell the bread by itself.

Just got a ? Italian sandwich. It was really good. It's cool they gift you a cookie ?. Thanks #HazyJavi ? on music streaming apps enjoy

Ordered French Dip. Easiest sandwich to make. Specified no “horseradish Mayo”, just Au Ju.The sandwich was so full of the “horseradish Mayo”, I couldn’t eat it. Apparently they don’t read orders correctly. Never had a problem with Mr. Pickles before. Not sure I’ll go back.

If you like mayo or sauces on your sandwich, this is the place for you. My wife loves it; I feel like all the sandwiches are a bit too messy for me. You'll have to decide for yourself, but the service is quite friendly. It's OK.

They were out of dutch crunch. Everything was great. They seemed to be doing online orders before in-store orders.

Order online 2 sandwiches and kids' sandwich. The estimated time it would be ready online said 15 mins. When I got there within 10 mins, I was told I was earlier and they would start my order soon. Waited AN HOUR before I actually received my order. When I arrived 4 people came and ordered and received theirs before I did. HORRIBLE SERVICE.

At this time, there's no indoor seating. They told me that they are not planning on changing to seating anytime soon, so even though their sandwiches are okay, I will probably pass on going there in the future. I get the concern about COVID, but I think they could manage if they wanted to like many other restaurants do, If I want the food truck experience, then I'll go to a food truck instead. I would just like to eat my sandwich at the place where I purchased it.

Ordered onlineI picked up the sandwiches got to the house and the entire order was wrong! I had to go back down to the shop and have them redo the order. The tuna sandwich had less than a tablespoon of tuna, when they remade the tuna it had the same amount that it did the first time! To sum it up mr. Pickles needs to hire competent employees.

ordered a vegetarian sandwich waited 40 minutes just for it to have roast beef in it. horrible customer service had to order and pay again just to wait another 40 minutes. would give 0 stars if i could

This is the same kind of place as Subway and Togo's. I like both those places and go to both, but Mr Pickle's is significantly better than either one of them. Significantly better. When I finsh eating I think, Damn, that was a good sandwich! Plus they have really nice potato salad and macaroni salad--in addition to every kind of chips known to mankind.