Johnny Carino's

535 N 46th St, Rogers - 72756
260 reviews
Italian Pizza Seafood
(479) 633-0544

This place has REALLY gone downhill.My husband and I came in because we used to frequent this place a lot but we’re moving and wanted to visit one more time since there are no locations where we’re moving.The host was super slow to seat us. And they weren’t on a wait. Said he’d clean off a table “real quick.” Took him 15 minutes.Our server was either new or burnt out. She was very spacey, slow and not friendly at all. Didn’t know any of the drinks or beer on tap. Cut me off when I tried to order our appetizer when she took our drink order.There were times she walked by and looked right at the empty glasses and dirty dishes but didn’t ask if we wanted more to drink or more bread.The salads came out before the appetizer. They didn’t put the dressing on the side like I asked. My husband’s salad barely had any dressing. We asked twice for extra dressing, salt and pepper. By the time she brought it, we were already done.The stuffed mushrooms were gross. Cold and the sauce was watery.The food was nothing like we remember. My entree was cold and my husband’s noodles were hard like they’d been sitting out for a while. I overheard the host saying “Oh yeah their food was up there for a while but I couldn’t take them because I was busy.”I did say something about my cold entree and the mushrooms but nothing was compensated. My husband didn’t want to complain about his food.They did remake my entree, which was nice.We were both so disappointed. $102 ($82 bill plus $20 tip) for mediocre food and garbage service.Never again.

Really good food and service. Love the lasagna. Wish I had pics. I'll take some next time. Prices are adjusted for recent inflation so don't expect to spend $10 on a plate. It's a little higher. It's good though.

I will say we got there late but that was no excuse. It was almost an hour till close and we waited over 10 minutes to be seated. Our waitress was more absent than I would have liked but efficient. The food is the only reason this is a 4 star review. It was delicious.

The food was fantastic and the service great. Like so many restaurants they are experiencing a staffing shortage. But Jamie was a wonderful server and she really took great care of our large party of 9!

We came in kinda late but they were super kind to us and made us feel really great, even though we were clearly the only people there and they were closing things up in the back. Food was absolutely scrumptious, service was relaxed and cheerful, loved it. Will go back.

Our party of 6 arrived on a Sunday at 11:40. Only 3 tables were seated and no one waiting. It was 15 minutes before we were greeted. It was 1:10PM before we received our food, 90 minutes later. While we were waiting we visited the restrooms which had clearly not been cleaned since the day before. Likewise the floors in the bar area were not clean… very sticky. Makes me wonder about the kitchen. Food was average. Servers were working hard, but obviously understaffed.

Pretty subpar food. The restaurant was very clean though. I got the spicy fettuccine Alfredo and it just tasted like canned cheese put on noodles. My partner got the spicy cheese ravioli and it tasted just like nacho cheese put on ravioli. It was pretty disappointing. The Caesar salad also tasted like it had been next to shrimp so I wasn’t able to finish it. The bread and oil was very good at least. Our server also wasn’t too attentive because she wasn’t supposed to be there that day and was in normal clothes. She seemed to get confused when looking at IDs for alcohol for customers too. Probably won’t be coming back.

My birthday dinner. Order was incorrect when it arrived at our table. While my husband had his meal, I had to wait 50 minutes for mine to be replaced. I just had the manager bring me a to-go box, my husband was finished eating by this time. Then, they did not bring the bill, we waited another 15-20min. Went to the hostess to pay or FULL bill. Oh, but they offered us a piece of cake.

Been awhile since we had been there. Service and food was good, in the past. Don't get me wrong, our waiter was great, kitchen staff not so much. Place was not very busy, but it took far to long to get our food on the table. Maybe they can find more help, soon. I will go back, but it will be a bit.

I miss the Risotto soup they used to have. I normally go for the Spicy Shrimp and Chicken. Never disappoints. Please give them a break as they are training new servers and improve their service.