TJ's Sandwich Shop & Hugs Ice Cream

2992 N College Ave, Fayetteville - 72703
154 reviews
Sandwich Shop
(479) 442-2929

We love TJ'S and the sandwiches are so yummy!! We order for my job a few times a month and we have several orders so we can all pay separate. Maybe 5-6 sandwiches. We call it in and give them notice we are coming and let them know we are paying separate. One guy who works the lunch shift is usually always there. He is so rude on the phone and acts so put out with our order that today 5/4/22 we decided to just go in and place our orders. Customer service from the same guy we deal with on the phone was just as horrible and rude in person. Hoping he's not the owner or manager. We won't be back but we will miss the sandwiches! One star for customer service or lack of.

The location has a comfortable classic diner kind of vibe and our family loves it. You order at the counter, and the employees we've dealt with have been polite and professional and not super talkative, which is fine with us, especially since they are very knowledgeable about the menu and they're fast. Sandwiches are delicious and the tomato soup...wow, so good. It's my favorite. Thankfully it is available daily! The only complaint I have is I wish they had reusable dishes and silverware.

First time to eat here and knew nothing about them. I'll be going back for sure. The bread, meats and cheese for the sandwich were a very good combination. The mac'n cheese side was very tasty. I believe they make it in house but I didn't ask. If you have a sweet tooth then give their ice cream a try. They have unique names and flavor but was good and worth the price.

Super happy to live near by! We had the Italian Stallion and the Gobbler both were really delicious, ingredients were great. We can't wait to come back and try some ice cream too!

Love this place! It’s become a favorite for my coworkers and I. Always fast, always friendly. Mel (I think is her name) has helped me through the drive thru the last two days and could not be more pleasant and sweet! Highly recommend!

Love this gem! The gobbler and Italian stallion are my faves! Soup is great too!!

I've had the Spicy Bird and The Robot. Both were fantastic sandwiches! I highly recommend giving these folks a try.

I love the TJ's Cheesesteak sandwich. I seem unable to order anything else because I always want that. I pair it with the Mac n cheese.

Yes service was excellent and so was the food there they have the sandwiches and specialty sandwiches they are very good I tried the club one and it was very good they also have pre-made like lasagna and meals like that it's meals for one or two people they're not large containers but they are absolutely delicious! But more than anything, they have the most excellent desserts and ice cream! they have handmade ice creams, there's at least a dozen they are delicious you have got to try them! I tried the Mom's Apple pie and oh my goodness, it's delicious! the salty caramel was a close second for me and the chocolate is so yummy n creamy! I can't wait to try them all!

I’ve heard good things about this sandwich shop, so I was quite surprised my first order was so disappointing. I ordered the Maui Waui. It sounded fresh and healthy, however everything’s tasted as if it were canned. The chicken and pineapple both looked and tasted like they came straight from a can. The bun tasted like a Brioche rather than sourdough. The bun also looked, felt, and tasted like it came from a bag out of the supermarket vs anything remotely fresh. The bun made the sandwich overly sweet probably being the other ingredients were already sweet. It did not sit well with my stomach.I might give the sandwich shop one more attempt, but as for now I’m not and fan and will not recommend it to anyone.