Big Whiskey's American Restaurant & Bar - Fayetteville

1320 N College Ave, Fayetteville - 72703
93 reviews
American Cocktail Bar
(479) 332-5200

Best burgers EVER!! Great staff and food. Highly reccomend.

I feel bad, but my Dad and I just ate here and the food was just not good. The steak was cold, the mashed potatoes were bland, the spinach dip was curdled, my soup was room temperature. Dad got a dessert and the brownie was not even warm in the least. Even the tea was tasteless. Crazy. Sorry, but Big Whiskey in Bentonville did way better.

The outdoor patio, large screen TVs, love the burgers and nachos

Always great food, service, and atmosphere. Some of our favorites are the fried green beans app, pretzel bites and cheese app, chicken tenders, and steak. Brunch is amazing as well. Great place to watch a game and drink a beer.

Fantastic foodAmazing service - everything came in perfect timingI truly don’t know why there’s bad reviews ??‍♀️I even got the queso wrap and subscribed the chicken for shrimp and it was SO GOOD .Dillion was our waiter and did a fantastic job.

Very nice assortment of steaks, chicken, pork dishesHas about 10 appetizersLiterally 100’s of likker drinks,I had double baileys coffeeWaitress was on her game, never missed a refill2 hungry people eating steaks and drinks , check was around $100 plus tipThank you Big Dub ya for nice experienceWill definitely go back!

10 out of 10 do not recommend. I try to be nice I really do but this was my first and last time ever going here. There was maybe 3 groups of people when we came in and first it took almost 10 minutes to get sat down same for the people behind us. Then we get sat down and hardly paid any attention to the waitress was not helpful at all didn’t care to check on us. I get my food and my burger wasn’t even cooked all the way still raw hamburger meet how lovely right? I also specifically asked is there any sauce that comes on that burger and she said no which is what I wanted that was a lie cause it was drenched in stuff. After sitting there for another 18 minutes very mad cause no one has came to ask me how my food is when I clearly wasn’t eating it. The workers were joking around taking pictures and playing on phones had some kid running in the back of the restaurant and stuff which isn’t safe at all or sanitary but anyways all this and I finally get someone to ask me how my food is and I refused to pay for that trash. Whatever cook they had in the back needs to find a new job cause that’s not cool you don’t serve people RAW HAMBURGER MEET. They need a whole new crew there, No wonder everyone I’ve told said “well yeah that’s the Fayetteville location they suck” screw this place it ruined my day I ate McDonald’s after I left and they did so much better.

We were greeted promptly and picked a table. We chose drinks and the pickle appetizer. It was really good. I had the ribeye, mashed potatoes and veggies. It was really good. My wife had a hamburger and fries. It was also really good. The reason I gave it a 4 of 5 was for two things 1. The put a 20% tip on the bill for two. Now we would have tipped more than that anyway but we thought that was a tad inappropriate. The other was the reason we went is I remember how much I loved the NY strip there. It’s on the internet but not on the post COVID menu we were told. It was a good experience

Brittney made great drinks and set the tone for a great vibe. Would definitely recommend to others :)

First time trying big whiskey and it was not disappointed. The food was amazing the staff was very friendly 10 put of 10 will be returning.