#1Brothers Pizza

16995 W Greenway Rd #104, Surprise - 85388
183 reviews
Pizza
(623) 544-3332

Stopped in to try this little place since it was near the grocery store. It is a clean little restaurant and a very friendly and helpful staff. However, I was not super impressed with the food. There's nothing really wrong with it, but it just really didn't meet my liking. The portion size of the spaghetti dinner was great and it comes with a large salad and bread. The bread was probably my favorite thing out of the whole meal. The spaghetti sauce flavor was just not resonating with me. It was a little bit too close to a chef boyardee / spaghetti-os flavor of sauce. The meatballs were pretty good though. The pizza was pretty decent as well, but just nothing extraordinary about it. Overall, not a bad place but not my first choice.

We just Love the place! It’s like home! Like family!! We have been going there since our youngest was 3 years old….Mira is our absolute favorite and the food is more than #1 in my book and always has been. Today we as a family decided to celebrate our youngest son’s graduation from high school there and we had the best experience, we even brought our whole family and everyone raves about the food!

Never a bad moment or experience with these guys and their food! Best pizza you can get IMO, and great people.I'll just say this, they make the only cheese pizza I've ever actually enjoyed eating...it's a pretty high bar.I've had people hit me up literally more than a year after I recommended it to them to let me know that they finally tried it, remembered my recommendation, and fully regret waiting as long as they did to give it a shot because they were missing out the entire time!

friendly atmosphere, awesome food and reasonably priced.

Awesome neighborhood pizza spot! Friendly staff and the pizza and calzone is delicious!!! Super fresh ingredients and very authentic, you must try!

I don’t get the negative reviews on here. Always perfect pizza when we order and having lived in NY for 8 years I can honestly say this is awesome pizza and the father and son behind the counter are always extremely welcoming and polite.

We've been going to this for 25+ years and last night we went there ordered pizza ,wings ,and salad My step dad found a bread tie in his salad. and the wings were so overcooked that we found not eat them So, that tells me that they are not paying attention.. Everything was disgusting and dry NOT the same as it was before. Nooooo.

Fantastic Hot Wings!!……..

This has not been the first time they mess up something, one time i got a completely different pizza than the one i ordered, i wish i was kidding. However, they have gone overboard this time, i don’t mind pizza being a little overdone but this is CRAZY- the pizza was soo burnt that the bite i took didn’t even want to come off the slice of pizza! what. && before you say anything I LOVE BROTHERS, the location on 75th and cactus is 11/10 pizza i don’t think they have ever messed up my pizza and it’s just really good.

My son and I came to grab a bite to eat with their lunch special. The gentleman at the front was very kind and helped me choose which special would be best for us. He let us know it would be ready in 5 minutes so we went to grab a drink at Frys and come back for our pizza. After we arrived it took about 15-20 min for him to hand us our pizza. We came straight home to eat which is right around the corner and the pizza was cold ? Not only that, the cheese wasn’t melted or the toppings on it. I worked for 2 years at a pizza joint in the past so I know what it’s supposed to look like, my bell peppers and mushrooms were raw still and crunchy not what you’d like on a pizza. The pepperoni looked like it needed extra time as well. Just a small suggestion- spread the ingredients so their not stacked on top and throw it back in the oven halfway to cook. The crust was good, cheese was good too. So more of a 3.5 stars for the unnecessary long wait, cold pizza, and uncooked ingredients. Will try them again and hopefully raise my stars!