Using a Groupon to try this place we ordered a veggie pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parmesan over ziti, and 2 cheesecake. Chris from Long Island took great care of us and while we waited for our to go order, he was so engaging. He went on break and Jack took over, helping me carry everything to the car, he was so polite. We spoke to an older couple waiting for there order and they are regulars, love the food and service as well. The sauce on the pizza was fantastic and I found out they sell it by the pint. Also we had the pasta the next night for dinner and lunch the day after as it was so much food. Both were excellent, we will definitely be back here to try some more great food. Thanks for your great service guys!! Only negative is they forgot the cherry sauce for our cheesecake, next time!!
Wow, a great locally owned Italian place with excellent pizza, subs and wings. Pricing is not bad either. Never had a bad meal there. If you like NY style pizza, come here to get it! Superb.
Godfather pizza was awesome. Meatballs a great appetizer. First time ordering and will do again. I didn't receive chicken on my salad but I ordered with Postmates so who knows on the chicken. It wasn't a big deal. Everything else tasted great.
Ate here on our trip to Scottsdale and so glad we did! We got a huge pizza, pasta and bread. Every thing tasted delicious! The girl in the front was super friendly, my kids enjoyed talking to her. It was such a friendly, welcoming environment with good food.
So I’ve had the pizza there before. I don’t know if the cooks are different or they’re just not paying attention. Both pies the bottom was burnt. It really took away from the flavor. I grew up eating pizza in Brooklyn so I know my pizza. This would’ve been spot on if it weren’t for the crust. If I wanted burnt pizza, I’d go to a coal fired pizza joint.Never cook a pie where the crust on the bottom is black.Very disappointed.
Personalized service. Authentic New York style pizza. Quality ingredients in the salad. Serve yourself soda bar. Pro tip: wait a couple of minutes for your pizza to set, before you eat it, or all the toppings will fall off. ReaRealrecommend it!
Expected some amazing pizza. Sadly, it left me wanting! Very thin, crisp crust with very little sauce or cheese and sparse toppings for $14! That’s the 10 inch. All the toppings slid off when I tried to take a bite☹️ Long wait for your food due to all the take out orders! At least on a Saturday evening.The stars are for the excellent, friendly, helpful service from Mike! And the complimentary garlic knots-very good.It’s pretty loud in the place and if you’re into the game, this is your place! Tight parking with several restaurants and shops competing for the spots. I won’t be back.
Called in an order about six months ago and had no problems other than pizza was ready 5 minutes after stated time. Last night I called in a pizza order and was told it would be 45 minutes. I arrived at the scheduled time and was told it would be 5 more minutes. I paid and gave a $5 tip on a $24.00 pizza. 20 minutes later, I inquired about my pizza and was told it would be an additional 10 minutes. It appears they do not place the order when you call, rather when you are there to pick up and pay. Very unprofessional. I got a refund and went elsewhere.
Service was friendly and fantastic! Ordered large ziggy and it was excellent. Crust was super light. They were giving a serving of garlic knots and sauce while we waited. $36 with tip for pizza and pop
I am from the BX and I tell you what, Yo Pauly's pizza is no joke. The pizza ? is on point, delicious, and crazy addictive. The staff is amazing, welcoming, and is extremely humble. I can't imagine not coming here for their delicious pizza and their lunch special prices. Come on down and taste pizza as it is intended to taste.