I have been going here occasionally since the business opened inside the Chevron Gas Station at the South-West corner of Brown and Recker and generally had great experience with the food. Unfortunately, when I ordered their fried mushrooms today; they were served very under cooked from the precious times I have ordered them. Unless I am mistaken and the previous times they were over cooked i am Unfortunately dissatisfied with the quality of the food I received today. I will be returning as the food is generally a good quality. The cheesecake was absolutely delicious.
NOT even close to NY Pizza. Those of you who left a good review are very very wrong. I ordered a regular cheese pie and it was disgusting. Salty and covered in Parmesan cheese and I think even cheddar. Garlic knots were almost raw and the marinara sauce with it was watered down and sweet. Will not be going back.
Flew in from L.A. decided to hit this spot after reading Good reviews. Turns out they were Right...You would NEVER think this Pizza joint, inside a Chevron Gas Station, would Be so fricken Delicious! And they made our wings Xtra Crispy as requested. In addition, the Staff was Super Welcoming. We Give this place a TOP GUN Rating!!!
Don’t let the gas station front fool you, this pizza is well worth the skepticism. Mother in law suggested it, and I now suggest this place for a delicious pie and wings. Friendly people with quality service! (They also like my hat)
I've had lots of different New York style pizza while living on the east coast for years. Tried this place and they had many menu items and their pizza crust impressed me. Good amount of cheese and sauce like the east coast. Definitely enjoyed my pizza. Will come again:)
Put in a big order on what turned out to be Superbowl Sunday. These guys got the order together in good time anyway. The pizza was great. Everyone in my very large family loved it. The prices are reasonable too, considering the fresh ingredients and the sizes of pizzas.
I've had lots of different New York style pizza while living on the east coast for years. Tried this place and they had many menu items and their pizza crust impressed me. Good amount of cheese and sauce like the east coast. Definitely enjoyed my pizza. Will come again:)
Wow. When I pulled up I was skeptical but as an avid reviewer, I was hopeful. Y'all .... This place was great. Pizza was great. Cheese sticks were good. The only complaint was the marinara wasn't what I was expecting. I feel like my assumption was that it was going to be thick, Americanized marinara. It seemed to be homemade and thinner than I expected. Flavor was good but I was expecting something different. We will be coming back here for sure!
I'm from Long Island and I grade pizza pretty tough. Everyone claims to have pizza like New York. Reality is some come close but not the same. This place is actually very close. It is now my go-to pizzeria. I've tried the grandma Pizza, The marinara pizza, The cheese pizza and the Italian Hero. They're all were delicious. I think it's better than red white and brews pizza and Venezia. Don't be scared by the appearance, that it's a pizzeria in a gas station
As a former Brooklynite I'm always on the hunt for good pizza...this place is the best! Tried a cheese pie first & it was delicious..just ordered a Bianco (White) pie, it was outstanding. So happy to have a good pizza place in my neighborhood..can't wait to try other menu items..